Insight

Trial by Hire

Tips for a jury trial preparation

Representing Children in a Divorce
JH

John F. Hill

September 18, 2019 02:30 PM

Legal commentators routinely sound the alarm about the scarcity of civil jury trials in our courts. Equally alarming: how frequently those rare jury trials are tried by so-called litigators—even those with some years under their belt—who lack meaningful jury-trial experience.

This problem harms clients and puts the legal professional’s reputation at risk. Despite their decline in frequency, jury trials continue to decide our largest and most important civil disputes.

Clients and “experienced litigators” alike mistakenly believe that litigation skills and experience are fungible. They assume that a lawyer who has litigated bench trials, complex arbitrations, or injunction hearings must also possess the requisite aptitude to persuade jurors. Too often they’re wrong. Context is crucial—and so is practice. Just because a lawyer has tried a few jury trials, or even won a verdict or two, doesn’t necessarily mean he’s trying cases with excellence. As a judge once remarked upon taking a jury verdict in a poorly tried case: “In our system, someone has to win.”

How can we make sure clients facing civil jury trials will receive expert, high-level service? How can we be certain jurors will sit for a trial that enables them to do their job properly—and to enjoy their service as much as possible? One way is to request a “last-minute” trial consultation.

What Is a Last-Minute Trial Consultation?

A last-minute consultation is an evaluation provided by highly experienced jury-trial lawyers in a lawsuit with, yes, an impending jury trial. These consultations are especially important when a case is disrupted due to a key witness giving surprising testimony at deposition, or when a client lacks confidence in litigation counsel’s evaluation or trial preparation. In these circumstances, a consult with an experienced jury-trial lawyer can help calm the waters.

Despite their name, these consults should occur well before the trial date—roughly 90 to 120 days, ideally. Depending on the case and the issues to be tried, though, they can be useful even if they happen just weeks in advance.

What Are Common Warning Signs That Your Case Needs a Last-Minute Trial Consultation?

There are many red flags that indicate you need help outside of your immediate trial team. The most common:

1. Your case is growing larger and less comprehensible as trial approaches. Done properly, litigation should gradually narrow the issues the jury will decide. Even the largest civil cases eventually winnow to a figurative handful of key documents and issues. If instead your case is expanding to include more parties, new claims and defenses, newly discovered documents, and endless procedural motions and disputes, something is awry, and properly preparing for trial becomes extremely difficult. A fresh look from an experienced trial lawyer can help your team decide which battles deserve to be fought, and whether they’re being properly prepared for the jury.

2. You feel like you’re in an echo chamber. As a general rule, civil cases go to trial when one side is making a serious mistake in evaluating its case: They’re not imagining, discussing and truly hearing the opposing point of view. They’re not subjecting their key witnesses to rigorous mock cross-examination and honest (but constructive) feedback. They’ve grown too close to their case and too enamored of their own advocacy. This is part of the recipe for a bad verdict. Excellent jury-trial lawyers rigorously test and challenge their case theories early and often. A last-minute consultation with an experienced jury-trial lawyer can provide invaluable help with this.

3. Your case lacks a coherent story that will help educate and persuade the jury. As the trial approaches, your litigation team must develop a jury-friendly story. The team—lawyers and witnesses—must know the story and train themselves to communicate in the words and themes you’ll present. When being introduced to a pending case, we always ask (and expect) a team to be able to succinctly tell us their side—their story—in words a jury will understand. Surprisingly often, neither client nor lawyer can do this. Frequently, they’ve allowed their opponent to frame the case, and they’re simply reacting to the opponent’s story. For example, as the defense team, you should not persistently describe your case as a “whistleblower case” if you deny that the plaintiff was a whistleblower. Similarly, are you defending a “fraud case” or a “seller’s-remorse case”? Why do the lawyers repeatedly talk about the “contract claim” while the client speaks only about fiduciary duties? If your team isn’t collectively immersed in its trial story and verbiage as the trial approaches, you need a consult to hone your message.

"Excellent jury-trial lawyers rigorously test and challenge their case theories early and often."

Will this consultation disrupt our case or our client relationship?

Experienced jury-trial lawyers honor the importance of the team. They define and respect the roles of each member. They can take a role on your trial team without disrupting your case. A last-minute consultation can be limited to pretrial consulting assistance (such as helping identify and adjust jury themes, preparing voir dire, or assisting with key witness preparation), or it can involve active—first- or second-chair—participation at trial. Lawyers who provide this service take pride in refraining from disrupting long-term attorney-client relationships.

What fee arrangements can we use?

Last-minute consultations can operate via traditional hourly billing or alternative arrangements. Depending on the scope of services, the consultation can employ success fees, capped fees, contingent fees, or other hybrid-fee arrangements.

To truly serve our clients (and the jurors), lawyers should seek last-minute trial consultations more often. Litigators experienced in complex arbitrations and bench trials are accomplished professionals, but such experience doesn’t necessarily translate to jury-trial excellence. A last-minute consult with a highly experienced jury-trial lawyer can support your litigation team, bringing great value at little risk.

John Hill is Buckingham’s Litigation Practice Group Chair. He is a trial attorney who represents business owners, with a focus on doctors, lawyers, and other professionals. John has tried approximately 75 civil cases to juries over a 30-year career. He handles cases involving business interference, shareholder disputes, contract and insurance disputes, and other complex commercial litigation. John serves as boardroom counselor for clients who recognize the value and perspective an experienced courtroom lawyer can bring to a dispute before litigation begins.

Headline Image: UNSPLASH.COM/DANIEL NORIN, GUY BASABOSE

Related Articles

IN PARTNERSHIP

Trial Lawyers Protect Employees, Make Workplaces Safer


by Esquire Bank

Trial lawyers Jeffrey Laffey and Sean Flaherty fight hard for injured workers because of their own personal experiences with the aftermath of workplace injuries.

Lawyers Jeffrey Laffey and Sean Flaherty Protect Employees

IN PARTNERSHIP

How a Trial Lawyer Overcame Adversity and Is Paying It Forward


by Esquire Bank

After fighting to take the bar exam, Matt Nakajima continues to beat the odds for his clients as a personal injury trial lawyer, winning millions in settlements.

Trial Lawyer Matt Nakajima Overcame Adversity and Gives Back

IN PARTNERSHIP

Civil Litigation: How Trial Lawyers’ Efforts Help Communities


by Esquire Bank

There are many upfront costs when trying cases on a contingency fee model. However, Reza Torkzadeh is willing to fight to get the justice his clients deserve.

How Lawyers Like Reza Torkzadeh Help Communities

IN PARTNERSHIP

Justice For Maui


by Justin Smulison

The Maui wildfires were the 5th deadliest wildfire in the U.S. James Frantz was quick to team up with Leavitt, Yamane & Soldner, providing crucial resources.

Group of lawyers pose for picture

IN PARTNERSHIP

When the Result Means Everything


by Lyons & Simmons

Michael Lyons and Christopher Simmons, Texas-based trial attorneys and founders of the firm Lyons & Simmons, are dedicated to finding justice for their clients.

Two suited lawyers walk side by side while talking

IN PARTNERSHIP

Leadership and Commitment


by Justin Smulison

Malone Law leader and 2016 Medical Malpractice Law – Plaintiffs “Lawyer of the Year” Adam Malone discusses how his success transcends the courtroom and helps strengthen public and legal communities.

Suited man standing with arm resting on table

IN PARTNERSHIP

Protecting the Public


by Justin Smulison

Burg Simpson founder and three-time Best Lawyers® “Lawyer of the Year” honoree Michael S. Burg discusses the impact of the firm’s national cases and how its trial lawyers continue to add to the firm’s 45-year legacy.

Lawyers pose for headshot with black background

Colorado's Best Lawyers 2022


by Best Lawyers

Our 2022 Colorado's Best Lawyers publication features top-ranked legal talent in Boulder, Denver and Western Colorado.

Colorado's Best Lawyers 2022

Selection Protection


by Robert A. Clifford and Bradley M. Cosgrove

Jury Research in High Profile Cases

Jury Research in High Profile Cases

How to Prepare Your Witness


by Kyle Sherman

A trial consultant gives advice on how to prepare your witness for depositions and trials.

The Importance of Witness Preparation

A Trial Icon


by Sean Stonefield

Dan Cogdell on his almost four decades of courtroom success.

Dan Cogdell Best Lawyers 2020

Does Gender Play a Role in Selecting Expert Witnesses?


by Kristin Hackler

The jury is out.

The Question of Gender Bias

Combating Punitive Damages Awards on Appeal


by Lynn Kappelman and Dawn Solowey

While the trial team’s deep knowledge of the trial record is an important resource, if that team does not also have appellate experience, consider an appellate specialist to lead the next phase of the case.

Punitive Damages

Safeguarding the Community


by Sean Stonefield

When companies put profits over safety, trial attorney Daniel J. T. Sciano steps in.

Daniel J. T. Sciano of Tinsman & Sciano, Inc

Driven, Obsessed, and Loving Every Minute


by Susan K. Bozorgi

Cris Arguedas on defending the accused.

Driven Obsessed

Trending Articles

Introducing the 2026 Best Lawyers Awards in Australia, Japan, New Zealand and Singapore


by Jennifer Verta

This year’s awards reflect the strength of the Best Lawyers network and its role in elevating legal talent worldwide.

2026 Best Lawyers Awards in Australia, Japan, New Zealand and Singapore

Discover The Best Lawyers in Spain 2025 Edition


by Jennifer Verta

Highlighting Spain’s leading legal professionals and rising talents.

Flags of Spain, representing Best Lawyers country

How to Increase Your Online Visibility With a Legal Directory Profile


by Jennifer Verta

Maximize your firm’s reach with a legal directory profile.

Image of a legal directory profile

Effective Communication: A Conversation with Jefferson Fisher


by Jamilla Tabbara

The power of effective communication beyond the law.

 Image of Jefferson Fisher and Phillip Greer engaged in a conversation about effective communication

Paramount Hit With NY Class Action Lawsuit Over Mass Layoffs


by Gregory Sirico

Paramount Global faces a class action lawsuit for allegedly violating New York's WARN Act after laying off 300+ employees without proper notice in September.

Animated man in suit being erased with Paramount logo in background

The Future of Family Law: 3 Top Trends Driving the Field


by Gregory Sirico

How technology, mental health awareness and alternative dispute resolution are transforming family law to better support evolving family dynamics.

Animated child looking at staircase to beach scene

The 2025 Legal Outlook Survey Results Are In


by Jennifer Verta

Discover what Best Lawyers honorees see ahead for the legal industry.

Person standing at a crossroads with multiple intersecting paths and a signpost.

Safe Drinking Water Is the Law, First Nations Tell Canada in $1.1B Class Action


by Gregory Sirico

Canada's argument that it has "no legal obligation" to provide First Nations with clean drinking water has sparked a major human rights debate.

Individual drinking water in front of window

New Mass. Child Custody Bills Could Transform US Family Law


by Gregory Sirico

How new shared-parenting child custody bills may reshape family law in the state and set a national precedent.

Two children in a field holding hands with parents

The Best Lawyers Network: Global Recognition with Long-term Value


by Jamilla Tabbara

Learn how Best Lawyers' peer-review process helps recognized lawyers attract more clients and referral opportunities.

Lawyers networking

Jefferson Fisher: The Secrets to Influential Legal Marketing


by Jennifer Verta

How lawyers can apply Jefferson Fisher’s communication and marketing strategies to build trust, attract clients and grow their practice.

Portrait of Jefferson Fisher a legal marketing expert

Finding the Right Divorce Attorney


by Best Lawyers

Divorce proceedings are inherently a complex legal undertaking. Hiring the right divorce attorney can make all the difference in the outcome of any case.

Person at a computer holding a phone and pen

The Future of Canadian Law. Insights from Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch Honorees


by Jennifer Verta

Emerging leaders in Canada share their perspectives on the challenges and opportunities shaping the future of Canadian law

Digital eye with futuristic overlays, symbolizing legal innovation and technology

New Texas Law Opens Door for Non-Lawyers to Practice


by Gregory Sirico

Texas is at a critical turning point in addressing longstanding legal challenges. Could licensing paralegals to provide legal services to low-income and rural communities close the justice gap?

Animated figures walk up a steep hill with hand

Is Your Law Firm’s Website Driving Clients Away?


by Jamilla Tabbara

Identify key website issues that may be affecting client engagement and retention.

Phone displaying 'This site cannot be reached' message

Family Law Wrestles With Ethics as It Embraces Technology


by Michele M. Jochner

Generative AI is revolutionizing family law with far-reaching implications for the practice area.

Microchip above animated head with eyes closed