Insight

Philadelphia Court Rejects Expert Methodology for Detecting Asbestos

Philadelphia Court Rejects Expert Methodology for Detecting Asbestos

Christian Singewald

Christian Singewald

May 9, 2019 10:08 AM

By: Christian Singewald, Wesley Payne and Jonathan Woy

Lawsuits against talcum powder manufacturers have recently made headlines for the multimillion dollar verdicts returned in favor of plaintiffs with ovarian cancer. However, lawsuits brought by individuals with mesothelioma who did not work in occupations traditionally associated with asbestos exposure represent another potential liability for talcum powder manufacturers and retailers. In such cases, expert testimony linking mesothelioma to trace amounts of asbestos in talcum powder should be carefully scrutinized.

In Philadelphia, two experts were recently prohibited from testifying in a lawsuit brought by a plaintiff who claimed her mesothelioma was caused by exposure to asbestos in talcum powder. In Brandt v. The Bon-Ton Stores, Inc., the plaintiff sought to introduce an experimental pathologist’s opinion that asbestos in the talcum powder caused her mesothelioma. The pathologist admitted that he modified several different generally accepted methodologies for evaluating the causal connection between mesothelioma and asbestos exposure. The plaintiff also sought to introduce a geologist’s testimony that the talcum powder she used contained a significant number of asbestos fibers that would have been released when she used the powder. The methodology underlying the geologist’s opinion consisted of individual elements of several different generally accepted asbestos detection protocols. The court described his approach as “a mishmash of scientifically accepted methodologies” selected for the purpose of reaching a desired but not scientifically valid result.

Because of the influential nature of expert testimony, courts act as a gatekeeper to ensure experts’ opinions are based on sound scientific principles. When the methodology underlying an expert’s opinion is challenged, the party offering the expert must prove that the expert’s methodology is generally accepted in the relevant field. Because both experts in Brandt modified and therefore deviated from generally accepted methodology, the court determined that neither expert’s contrived methodology met the requirements of the Frye or Betz tests. Accordingly, the court deemed their opinions to be inadmissible.

If you have any questions or would like additional information, please contact Christian Singewald (singewaldc@whiteandwilliams.com; 302.467.4510), Wesley Payne (paynew@whiteandwilliams.com; 215.864.7076), or Jonathan Woy (woyj@whiteandwilliams.com; 215.864.6354).

Related Articles

Pribanic Secures Milestone Verdict in Rural PA County


by Justin Smulison

Ten-time honoree Victor H. Pribanic secured one of 2023’s most notable verdicts in a Pennsylvania county that historically has not been empathic to plaintiffs.

Lawyer sitting at desk with notepad and laptop

IN PARTNERSHIP

The Immeasurable Impact of Advocacy


by Justin Smulison

Burg Simpson founder Michael S. Burg discusses how the firm’s results transcend the courtroom to improve life for consumers and professionals nationwide.

Lawyer posing in a checker suit

We Are Women, We Are Fearless


by Deborah S. Chang and Justin Smulison

Athea Trial Lawyers is a female owned and operated law firm specializing in civil litigation, catastrophic energy, wrongful death and product liability.

Athea Trial Law Female Leadership and Success

Catastrophic Personal Injury


by Best Lawyers

Trial legend Frank Branson finds success mixing technology and new skills with vast courtroom experience.

Catastrophic Personal Injury

Engineered for Success


by Justin Smulison

Koskoff’s product-liability leader, Bill Bloss, explains how his group combines legal knowledge with engineering insight for the benefit of their clients—and future consumers as well

Bill Bloss Best Lawyers 2020

A Cohesive Team


by Best Lawyers

How Bentley & More LLP Combined Forces

A Cohesive Team

Media Tips in a High-Profile Case


by Gregory G. Rizio

How an Attorney Can Successfully Work With the Press

Media Tips in a High-Profile Case

A Warrior for Clients


by Best Lawyers

Michael P. Lyons stands up.

Lyons Roaring Through Complex Disputes

Unlocking an Auto Product Safety Mystery


by Best Lawyers

After a rear-end collision left their two young children with severe head injuries, the Reavis family had many questions and no one to turn to for help.

Frank L. Branson Toyota Payout

E-Scooters: Spontaneous Fun or Serious Danger?


by Linda J. Chalat

Reports of serious injury raise questions over the legality of electric scooters—even as ridership grows.

Are E-Scooters Legal in Colorado?

Roundup, Dangerous Products


by Joseph Fantini

In recent years, there’s been a significant increase in product liability lawsuits filed in California.

Dangerous Products in California

Rebuilding Faith in the Legal System


by Margo Pierce

Burg Simpson lawyers discuss what drives them to fight for consumers and significant cases in their consumer advocacy.

Burg Simpson's Legal Strategy

Trending Articles

Introducing the 2026 Best Lawyers Awards in Australia, Japan, New Zealand and Singapore


by Jennifer Verta

This year’s awards reflect the strength of the Best Lawyers network and its role in elevating legal talent worldwide.

2026 Best Lawyers Awards in Australia, Japan, New Zealand and Singapore

How to Increase Your Online Visibility With a Legal Directory Profile


by Jennifer Verta

Maximize your firm’s reach with a legal directory profile.

Image of a legal directory profile

Effective Communication: A Conversation with Jefferson Fisher


by Jamilla Tabbara

The power of effective communication beyond the law.

 Image of Jefferson Fisher and Phillip Greer engaged in a conversation about effective communication

Paramount Hit With NY Class Action Lawsuit Over Mass Layoffs


by Gregory Sirico

Paramount Global faces a class action lawsuit for allegedly violating New York's WARN Act after laying off 300+ employees without proper notice in September.

Animated man in suit being erased with Paramount logo in background

The Future of Family Law: 3 Top Trends Driving the Field


by Gregory Sirico

How technology, mental health awareness and alternative dispute resolution are transforming family law to better support evolving family dynamics.

Animated child looking at staircase to beach scene

The 2025 Legal Outlook Survey Results Are In


by Jennifer Verta

Discover what Best Lawyers honorees see ahead for the legal industry.

Person standing at a crossroads with multiple intersecting paths and a signpost.

Safe Drinking Water Is the Law, First Nations Tell Canada in $1.1B Class Action


by Gregory Sirico

Canada's argument that it has "no legal obligation" to provide First Nations with clean drinking water has sparked a major human rights debate.

Individual drinking water in front of window

New Mass. Child Custody Bills Could Transform US Family Law


by Gregory Sirico

How new shared-parenting child custody bills may reshape family law in the state and set a national precedent.

Two children in a field holding hands with parents

The Best Lawyers Network: Global Recognition with Long-term Value


by Jamilla Tabbara

Learn how Best Lawyers' peer-review process helps recognized lawyers attract more clients and referral opportunities.

Lawyers networking

Jefferson Fisher: The Secrets to Influential Legal Marketing


by Jennifer Verta

How lawyers can apply Jefferson Fisher’s communication and marketing strategies to build trust, attract clients and grow their practice.

Portrait of Jefferson Fisher a legal marketing expert

Finding the Right Divorce Attorney


by Best Lawyers

Divorce proceedings are inherently a complex legal undertaking. Hiring the right divorce attorney can make all the difference in the outcome of any case.

Person at a computer holding a phone and pen

The Future of Canadian Law. Insights from Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch Honorees


by Jennifer Verta

Emerging leaders in Canada share their perspectives on the challenges and opportunities shaping the future of Canadian law

Digital eye with futuristic overlays, symbolizing legal innovation and technology

Is Your Law Firm’s Website Driving Clients Away?


by Jamilla Tabbara

Identify key website issues that may be affecting client engagement and retention.

Phone displaying 'This site cannot be reached' message

New Texas Law Opens Door for Non-Lawyers to Practice


by Gregory Sirico

Texas is at a critical turning point in addressing longstanding legal challenges. Could licensing paralegals to provide legal services to low-income and rural communities close the justice gap?

Animated figures walk up a steep hill with hand

Family Law Wrestles With Ethics as It Embraces Technology


by Michele M. Jochner

Generative AI is revolutionizing family law with far-reaching implications for the practice area.

Microchip above animated head with eyes closed

A Guide to Workers' Compensation Law for 2025 and Beyond


by Bryan Driscoll

A woman with a laptop screen reflected in her glasses