Insight

Patent (Win) Pending

In every court proceeding, patent litigation included, there will be a winner and a loser. Everyone wants to win, but half lose. Why?

Winning Patent Litigation
Morgan Chu

Morgan Chu and Rebecca Carson

December 19, 2019 08:00 AM

Lawyers, understandably, want to win everything in patent litigation, or any litigation: every discovery dispute, every tit-for-tat argument. Most of these battles are of little moment.

You need, instead, to focus. Which issues—one, two, or three of the most crucial factors, say—will make you a winner? If your client is the plaintiff, choose your best patent claims. Eliminate those that are mediocre or even good; you’re looking for the best on offer. For a defendant, select the best several defenses. You might not be able to identify them at the outset, of course, but don’t use that as an excuse to maintain 37 different defenses up to trial.

In one David-and-Goliath case in which we represented the plaintiff (the underdog), we chose just one patent to assert, bypassing many other patents and a veritable chariot-load of non-patent claims. Remember the key to David’s success: one stone in a simple slingshot, aimed with precision.

Some defendants want to rely on many prior-art references, or many combinations of prior art, to show that a patent claim is “obvious.” Instead, they end up proving to a jury’s satisfaction that the claim is not obvious because they needed so many pieces of prior art. Pour your energy into only the best patent claims or the best defenses. Eschew all others.

Recognize Your Weaknesses

Lawyers love Kool-Aid—the kind they mix themselves, at any rate. It’s never good to drink your own, though. Spend more time understanding and appreciating the strength of the other side’s arguments.

People used to be better at this. It relies on a crucial skill called “listening.” Things have changed over the last decade or so, though: People no longer care to listen to different points of view, in politics or anything else. Attorneys have contracted this malady no less severely than others. Yet good lawyers will recognize their own case’s weaknesses, both component by component and in toto.

In one battle between two corporations of decent size, we represented the defendant. Our defenses were so poor that it was easy to regard this as a “damages” case for the plaintiff. As the trial unfolded, though, it appeared that the plaintiff didn’t recognize one potential weakness. Its witnesses hadn’t been prepared for it. Surprised, we changed our trial theme to focus on this particular weakness. Did it work? We wouldn’t be sharing this story if it hadn’t.

Consider the cross-examination of an expert witness. The witness is just that: the expert. That’s a problem for the lawyer. Don’t think you’ll easily pummel the expert into submission and win the case on your cross. Instead, assume the witness is his profession’s equivalent of Muhammad Ali. Wait until he’s dancing around the ring with his back to you, then jump through the ropes, give him two quick kidney punches and then jump back out. Congratulations: You’ve recognized your own weaknesses (and his strengths), and it earned you a couple points you might not otherwise have gotten.

Be Credible

That’s easy advice. Actually being credible is hard. This is especially true for lawyers who must orchestrate the presentation of evidence across multiple witnesses.

Sometimes witnesses initially seem important, but after a lot of work, you don’t think they’ll be credible. They think they are, of course—they consider themselves important, too—but they’re more likely to come across as literally in-credible. Cut them from your witness list.

Most lawyers want to try to control situations, naturally, and as a result they want to give a witness a script and tell him or her exactly what to say and how to say it. Resist this urge. While it’s important to pick the right witnesses on the right topics to support your trial themes, allow them to tell their stories in their own words. It requires a lot more time and effort, but permitting witnesses to be themselves will result in a much more authentic presentation.

Patent cases often come down to credibility battles between two technical experts. One says the patent is infringed; the other disagrees. Both have great credentials and technical chops. Who wins the jury verdict? The side with the more credible expert, of course.

Now the tough part: How can you help boost your expert’s credibility? Encourage him to be more modest, even humble, and admit weaknesses. Most importantly, make him into a teacher. Ninety-nine percent of people can remember a teacher they loved.

Regardless of how right you are on the facts and the law, no one will side with you unless you have a good story to tell.

Tell a Good Story

Patent cases often encompass dry, highly technical subjects. As such, lawyers can get lost in the weeds and forget about the need for a simple, compelling narrative that ties everything together. This is a critical mistake: Regardless of how right you are on the facts and the law, no one will side with you unless you have a good story to tell.

A good story requires more than simply stating the facts chronologically. You have to provide the jury with a narrative that evokes an emotional response and makes them connect with your client’s story on a human level. Come up with personal anecdotes that your witnesses can tell to help them connect with the jury while advancing your case themes.

In one case, we took over the representation of a medical-device defendant that had been found liable for infringement at a previous trial and was set to go to trial anew on the issue of damages and willfulness. The opposing side thought it would be enough to label us “bad guys” and ask for lots of money. But we responded with a compelling narrative told by longtime employees about how our client’s own innovations and devotion to superior patient care were the real reason for its success, not the plaintiff’s patented technology. The story was authentic; the jury found no willfulness and awarded minimal damages.

Focus. Recognize your weaknesses. Make your key expert into a kindly teacher. And tell a good story. Now have fun winning!

----------------

Morgan Chu heads Irell & Manella’s litigation practice. He has served as lead trial counsel in some of the world’s most significant verdicts, judgments, and settlements, resulting in actual payments exceeding $5 billion. He earned his J.D. from Harvard Law School, his M.S.L. from Yale University, and his B.A., M.A. and Ph.D. from University of California, Los Angeles.

Rebecca Carson, a partner at Irell & Manella, represents clients in complex commercial litigation and has significant trial experience, including recent trials in federal court and at the ITC. Her most recent patent trial victory was included among the Daily Journal’s Top Defense Verdicts of 2018. She earned her J.D. at University of Virginia School of Law and her B.A. at University of San Diego.

Photo: ISTOCK.COM/RICHLEGG

Related Articles

Combating Nuclear Verdicts: Empirically Supported Strategies to Deflate the Effects of Anchoring Bias


by Sloan L. Abernathy

Sometimes a verdict can be the difference between amicability and nuclear level developments. But what is anchoring bias and how can strategy combat this?

Lawyer speaking in courtroom with crowd and judge in the foreground

Protecting Small Business Owners: Trial Experts Connick Law LLC Notoriously Successful with Fire Litigation


by Justin Smulison

When small business owners become the target of insurance companies in fire-related lawsuits, hiring a firm with a reputation for understanding the science of fire suppression trials can save their livelihoods.

Gold Indoor Sprinkler Heads on Red Background

Will Recent Boeing Settlements Create Tailwinds In Corporate Law?


by Justin Smulison

Prominent litigation against Boeing is setting a precedent of accountability, professionalism and commitment among company boards as well as ushering ESG further into the courtroom to help monitor and prevent safety issues.

Recent Boeing Settlements and Corporate Law

Courtroom Mastery


by Justin Smulison

Victor H. Pribanic recalled the excitement of returning to the courtroom in late 2021 for a medical negligence case that could help set a new course for Pribanic & Pribanic’s trial advocacy.

Victor H. Pribanic Makes Return to Courtroom

Pennsylvania’s Best Lawyers 2022


by Best Lawyers

Our Pennsylvania’s Best Lawyers 2022 digital publication features top-ranked legal talent in Pennsylvania.

Pennsylvania’s Best Lawyers 2022

Helpful Hints & Avoidable Mistakes


by Frank L. Branson

I’ve picked up a lot in the courtroom in five decades of practice. Here are some strategies, tips and other pointers to help make your trial experience smoother—and successful.

Strategies for Plaintiff Lawyers in Trial

Colorado's Best Lawyers 2022


by Best Lawyers

Our 2022 Colorado's Best Lawyers publication features top-ranked legal talent in Boulder, Denver and Western Colorado.

Colorado's Best Lawyers 2022

Newly Launched COVID-19 Litigation Project Offers Open Access To Pandemic-Related Court Judgments From Over 70 Countries


by Sara Collin

A worldwide database of COVID-19 cases is uniting more than 70 countries as judges, lawmakers and lawyers continue to navigate pandemic related litigation and the ways in which it’s evolving amid year three.

COVID-19 Worldwide Litigation Project

Look for the Zoom Label


by Anne R. Yuengert and Matthew C. Lonergan

Will the virtual platforms that got such a boost during the pandemic replace how you interact with your employees, unions, and lawyers?

Virtual Platforms Replacing Work Interactions

Discovery in the Time of COVID-19


by H. Barber Boone

The pandemic has affected the vital process of legal discovery in ways both good and bad. Which changes are likely to become widely accepted in the years ahead?

The Impact of COVID-19 on E-Discovery

Busting a Trust


by Joseph Marrs

The rules governing trusts and asset distribution are often much more flexible than many might assume. Here’s a primer.

Rules Governing Trusts and Asset Distribution

The Next Chapter


by Patrick M. Shelby

Among its uncountable other disruptions, the pandemic upended U.S. bankruptcy procedures. Congressional relief, legislative changes, amended legal provisions: What lies ahead for those looking to file?

COVID-19's Impacts on Bankruptcy Procedures

Phoning It In


by Alyson M. St. Pierre, Ashley C. Pack and Crystal S. Wildeman

It’s not easy for employers to weigh requests from employees to work from afar, even in the wake of the pandemic. Considerations include COVID-19, vaccinations, the Americans with Disabilities Act and the nature of the job itself.

Employer Considerations for Teleworking

Compelled to Compete


by Ashish Mahendru

Courts and legislatures—and now the White House—are taking an increasingly dim view of noncompete employment agreements, a development the pandemic has quickened. What can employers do to protect their confidential information?

Protection for Employers Beyond Noncompetes

Meeting Halfway


by Julia B. Meister

To resolve family and business disputes including wills, trusts, estates and more, mediation is often a more effective, gentler and cheaper option than litigation.

Mediation to Resolve Wills, Trusts, Estates

IN PARTNERSHIP

Look Out Below


by Mary Jo Larson

Employee 401(k) and other pension plans that include company stock can be a financial minefield. What’s a responsible fiduciary to do to lessen the risk of a plummeting share price—and the risk of a subsequent “stock-drop” lawsuit from aggrieved workers?

Navigating Employee 401(k) and Pension Plans

Trending Articles

Presenting The Best Lawyers in Australia™ 2025


by Best Lawyers

Best Lawyers is proud to present The Best Lawyers in Australia for 2025, marking the 17th consecutive year of Best Lawyers awards in Australia.

Australia flag over outline of country

Best Lawyers Expands 2024 Brazilian Awards


by Best Lawyers

Best Lawyers is honored to announce the 14th edition of The Best Lawyers in Brazil™ and the first edition of Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch in Brazil™.

Image of Brazil city and water from sky

The Best Lawyers in Mexico Celebrates a Milestone Year


by Best Lawyers

Best Lawyers is excited to announce the 15th edition of The Best Lawyers in Mexico™ and the second edition of Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch in Mexico™ for 2024.

Sky view of Mexico city scape

How To Find A Pro Bono Lawyer


by Best Lawyers

Best Lawyers dives into the vital role pro bono lawyers play in ensuring access to justice for all and the transformative impact they have on communities.

Hands joined around a table with phone, paper, pen and glasses

How Palworld Is Testing the Limits of Nintendo’s Legal Power


by Gregory Sirico

Many are calling the new game Palworld “Pokémon GO with guns,” noting the games striking similarities. Experts speculate how Nintendo could take legal action.

Animated figures with guns stand on top of creatures

Announcing The Best Lawyers in New Zealand™ 2025 Awards


by Best Lawyers

Best Lawyers is announcing the 16th edition of The Best Lawyers in New Zealand for 2025, including individual Best Lawyers and "Lawyer of the Year" awards.

New Zealand flag over image of country outline

Presenting the 2024 Best Lawyers Family Law Legal Guide


by Best Lawyers

The 2024 Best Lawyers Family Law Legal Guide is now live and includes recognitions for all Best Lawyers family law awards. Read below and explore the legal guide.

Man entering home and hugging two children in doorway

Announcing The Best Lawyers in Japan™ 2025


by Best Lawyers

For a milestone 15th edition, Best Lawyers is proud to announce The Best Lawyers in Japan.

Japan flag over outline of country

The Best Lawyers in Singapore™ 2025 Edition


by Best Lawyers

For 2025, Best Lawyers presents the most esteemed awards for lawyers and law firms in Singapore.

Singapore flag over outline of country

Canada Makes First Foray Into AI Regulation


by Sara Collin

As Artificial Intelligence continues to rise in use and popularity, many countries are working to ensure proper regulation. Canada has just made its first foray into AI regulation.

People standing in front of large, green pixelated image of buildings

Commingling Assets


by Tamires M. Oliveira

Commingling alone does not automatically turn an otherwise immune asset into an asset subject to marital distribution as explained by one family law lawyer.

Toy house and figure of married couple standing on stacks of coins

How Much Is a Lawyer Consultation Fee?


by Best Lawyers

Best Lawyers breaks down the key differences between consultation and retainer fees when hiring an attorney, a crucial first step in the legal process.

Client consulting with lawyer wearing a suit

The Hague Convention and International Custody Battles


by Alexandra Goldstein

One family law lawyer explains how Joe Jonas and Sophie Turner’s celebrity divorce brings The Hague Convention treaty and international child custody battles into the spotlight.

Man and woman celebrities wearing black and standing for photo

Presenting the 2024 Best Lawyers Employment and Workers’ Compensation Legal Guide


by Best Lawyers

The 2024 Best Lawyers Employment and Workers' Compensation Legal Guide provides exclusive access to all Best Lawyers awards in related practice areas. Read below and explore the legal guide.

Illustration of several men and women in shades of orange and teal

New York Passes 9/11 Notice Act


by Gregory Sirico

Best Lawyers highlights the newly enacted 9/11 Notice Act, which seeks to find individuals eligible for medical care coverage under different federal programs.

Firefighter stands with their back turned with flames in the background

Filing For Divorce in North Carolina


by Melody J. King

Family law lawyer Melody King answers some of the most important questions individuals may have about filing for divorce in North Carolina.

Illustration of man and woman on paper that has been torn apart