Insight

How College Athletes Will Be Paid Under California’s Fair Pay to Play Act

Another Challenge to NCAA’s Financial Structure

College Athletes Will Be Paid Under New Law
HM

Hugh F. Murray III

October 30, 2019 02:00 PM

Katie Ledecky is the most dominant swimmer to attend college in the 21st century. In her Freshman year at Stanford University, she set 12 NCAA records, nine American records, and led the team to its first NCAA championship of the century. After a similarly spectacular sophomore year, with another NCAA team championship, Ledecky decided to start accepting money for professional endorsements. Because NCAA rules prohibit college athletes from accepting money for endorsements, this decision meant that Ledecky’s college career came to an end. Ledecky, like other superstar athletes before her, was undoubtedly aware that the window during which some athletes can earn substantial money is small and could be unexpectedly cut short by injuries or poor performance in the next season; waiting two more years could have meant that Ledecky might never make the kind of money her celebrity would be worth in 2018.

California's Fair Pay to Play Act

In September 2019, California passed a law that, had it been in effect in 2018, would have allowed Ledecky to make her commercial endorsements and continue to compete for Stanford. The Fair Pay to Play Act provides that neither California colleges and universities, nor any athletic association (like the NCAA) may prevent any student who is participating in intercollegiate athletics from earning compensation as a result of the use of the student’s name, image, or likeness.

With that law—which is not effective until January 1, 2023—California has joined in the ongoing debate about whether and how college athletes should share in the financial juggernaut that collegiate athletics has become. While its women’s swimming program—even with Ledecky—didn’t produce much revenue for Stanford or the NCAA, college football and basketball generate more than a billion (with a “b”) dollars each year for the educational institutions and their parent athletic organization. While coaches and administrators earn high salaries, NCAA athletes are prohibited from sharing in those riches beyond scholarships to their institutions and very modest stipends. In recent years, a number of lawsuits and legal claims have challenged the NCAA version of “amateurism," claiming that scholarship athletes are entitled to payment under one theory or another. So far, none of these claims have succeeded, but the California law represents yet another existential challenge to the NCAA’s core business model; given California’s size and economic power, it may be the biggest such threat yet. Alternatively, given the nature of the rights granted under the California law, the NCAA could instead adapt to this new rule without fundamentally changing its view of “amateur” collegiate athletics.

Prior challenges to the NCAA financing system have argued that student-athletes are directly entitled to a share of the revenues generated by their colleges from their efforts because they are effectively “employees” of the educational institutions.

College Athletes Try to Unionize

In 2015, for example, the National Labor Relations Board (“NLRB”) addressed whether scholarship athletes were “employees” under the National Labor Relations Act and thus eligible to vote to join a union. A Regional Office of the NLRB held a lengthy hearing on the issue in 2013 and decided, based on substantial evidence, that scholarship football players at Northwestern University met the various tests that the NLRB had established over the years for employee status because of the degree of control the school exercised over their activities and the various forms of “payment” (i.e. scholarships and stipends) the school provided. The NLRB Regional Office held an election and impounded the ballots while the full NLRB took up the issue.

In 2015, the NLRB essentially decided that it would not take a position on whether or not scholarship athletes were statutory employees. The board instead held that “asserting jurisdiction in this case would not serve to promote stability in labor relations.” The NLRB explicitly left the door open for a future, similar case, stating “whether we might assert jurisdiction in another case involving grant-in-aid scholarship football players (or other types of scholarship athletes) is a question we need not and do not address at this time.” The issue remains undecided.

A little more than a year later, a federal appeals court more directly addressed the issue of whether scholarship athletes qualify as employees under federal law. Several athletes who had competed with the University of Pennsylvania track and field program brought a lawsuit claiming that they and others were employees under the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) entitled to minimum wage and overtime pay. The United States Court of Appeals struggled to distinguish scholarship athletes from other categories of workers who had been afforded protection under the FLSA, but ultimately held that “[s]tudent participation in collegiate athletics is entirely voluntary. Moreover, the long tradition of amateurism in college sports, by definition, shows that student-athletes—like all amateur athletes—participate in their sports for reasons wholly unrelated to immediate compensation.” Berger et al. v. NCAA et al.

The California law is at once on more solid legal footing—there is no statutory interpretation needed—and potentially less threatening to the college sports model than the cases described above. Under the California law, the schools themselves would not be required to compensate the athletes, and the schools would remain free to refrain from, and the NCAA would remain free to restrict schools from, directly paying any athlete. The NCAA would remain free to require schools to refrain from brokering endorsement deals for student-athletes. The California law requires that student-athletes inform the schools of any such arrangements, which could facilitate NCAA oversight to prevent the schools and their formal alumni associations from brokering such deals. The schools will continue to control the use of their trademarks and uniforms, so the schools and the NCAA could adopt rules prohibiting student-athletes from displaying such trademarks and uniforms in connection with any endorsement deals. Thus, student-athletes like Katie Ledecky, whose value to sponsors derives far more from her individual accomplishments rather than the fact that she swims at Stanford, would likely be very successful as a product sponsor; in contrast, many other college athletes would have their value tied more closely to the fact that they, for example, are a member of the Ole Miss defensive line.

Treating student-athletes as employees of the colleges and universities they attend would fundamentally alter the relationship between schools and athletes. A large part of the appeal of college sports is the illusion that the participants are motivated purely by the love of the game and will for the most part stop playing at the end of four years and enter the “real world” with the rest of us. The California Fair Pay to Play Act, on the other hand, provides an avenue—if the NCAA chooses to pursue it—for the most talented and high profile athletes, the ability to both play college sports and earn money from endorsements. This may end up causing some star performers to stay longer in the NCAA and increase, rather than decrease, the value of collegiate sports.

POST-SCRIPT: As this article was going to press, on October 29, 2019, the NCAA Board of Governors voted unanimously to direct each of its three divisions to change rules to allow student-athletes “the opportunity to benefit from the use of their name, image, and likeness in a manner consistent with the collegiate model.” This step likely averts a no-win conflict between the NCAA and the world’s fifth-largest economy.

About the Author:

Employers turn to McCarter & English, LLP partner Hugh Murray to handle their employment and labor union matters, including addressing union-related issues ranging from organizational campaigns to collective bargaining to unfair labor practice charges to strikes. Hugh has been listed in The Best Lawyers in America for 13 years (2008-2020).

Related Articles

California Grad Student Strike Sparks Legal Free-Speech Battle


by Gregory Sirico

Graduate students in California strike over free speech rights amidst university crackdowns on Pro-Palestine protests, fueling an ongoing legal battle.

Megaphone held up by arm wrapped in barbed wire

IN PARTNERSHIP

Steps To Take After an Encino Car Accident


by Andrew L. Shapiro

Hurt in a car accident that wasn’t your fault? You may be able to recover compensation. Call JUSTICENTER Personal Injury Lawyers for a free consultation today.

Two people talk after a car accident

Prop 36 California 2024: California’s Path to Stricter Sentencing and Criminal Justice Reform


by Jennifer Verta

Explore how Prop 36 could shape California's sentencing laws and justice reform.

Illustrated Hands Breaking Chains Against a Bright Red Background

The Struggle Is Real


by Justin Smulison

Businesses are overlooking state and federal laws when downsizing or closing operations, driving a tidal wave of class action lawsuits from former employees.

Silhouetted figure has a tug of war with shadow

California Overhauls Controversial Private Attorneys General Act


by Eric C. Schwettmann and Katherine A. Hren

Enacted 20 years ago, PAGA is well behind the litigation curve in an age where change is always in motion.

Lawyer seated in an empty court

IN PARTNERSHIP

California Car Accident: How To File a Personal Injury Claim


by Robert T. Simon

Several steps are involved in filing a personal injury claim after a car accident in California. Read this article to learn about your legal rights and options.

Two lawyers meet to go over legal case

Key Developments and Trends in U.S. Commercial Litigation


by Justin Smulison

Whether it's multibillion-dollar water cleanliness verdicts or college athletes vying for the right to compensation, the state of litigation remains strong.

Basketball sits in front of stacks of money

An Employer’s Guidebook to Responding to Online Harassment


by Belle Harris and Brent Siler

Navigating online defamation against your business requires strategic responses. Two employment lawyers guide how to leverage contracts, understand social media limitations and the risks of legal action.

Image of person pushing giant phone with mouth and words coming out

IN PARTNERSHIP

What Are the Stages of a Criminal Case in California?


by Nafiz M. Ahmed

Criminal cases in California must follow proper procedures in court. One lawyer outlines each stage of a criminal case to offer guidance to all involved.

Person in grey sweatshirt with hands behind back in handcuffs being arrested by cop

Incendiary Behavior


by Lyssa A. Roberts and Rahul Ravipudi

California’s future will see more frequent wildfires caused by faulty equipment. Litigation tied to recent Golden State infernos shows the way forward.

Mountain range with glow of wildfires behind it

A Double Dose of Power


by Constance Endelicato

Women in the Legal and Medical Professions Can Work Together to Dismantle Gender Inequality

Women Work to Dismantle Gender Inequality

The Attorney You Choose Makes All the Difference


by A. Ilyas Akbari and Bobby Saadian

Choosing the right attorney for your lawsuit can make the difference for a successful outcome.

Choosing the Right Attorney For Your Needs

The Best Lawyers in Northern California


by Best Lawyers

Our 2022 Best Lawyers in Northern California publication features top-ranked legal talent in Fresno, Oakland, Sacramento, San Francisco, San Jose and Santa Rosa.

The Best Lawyers in Northern California

What Will a Car Accident Lawyer Actually Do for You?


by David Muñoz

Find out what you can expect after hiring a personal injury attorney. Learn about your legal rights to help you decide if you should hire an attorney after suffering injuries in a car accident.

What to Expect from A Personal Injury Lawyer

Avon Calling


by Rebecca Blackwell

Nostalgia-soaked childhood memories of the neighborhood "Avon lady" can mask an insidious reality: Multilevel marketing companies are often little more than polished Ponzi schemes. My experience is illustrative.

Multilevel Marketing Is Not Employment

Fighting for Justice


by Best Lawyers

How They Have Fought for Clients Every Step of the Way

Fighting for Justice

Trending Articles

2025 Best Lawyers Awards Announced: Honoring Outstanding Legal Professionals Across the U.S.


by Jennifer Verta

Introducing the 31st edition of The Best Lawyers in America and the fifth edition of Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch in America.

Digital map of the United States illuminated by numerous bright lights

Unveiling the 2025 Best Lawyers Awards Canada: Celebrating Legal Excellence


by Jennifer Verta

Presenting the 19th edition of The Best Lawyers in Canada and the 4th edition of Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch in Canada.

Digital map of Canadathis on illuminated by numerous bright lights

Legal Distinction on Display: 15th Edition of The Best Lawyers in France™


by Best Lawyers

The industry’s best lawyers and firms working in France are revealed in the newly released, comprehensive the 15th Edition of The Best Lawyers in France™.

French flag in front of country's outline

Presenting the 2025 Best Lawyers Editions in Chile, Colombia, Peru and Puerto Rico


by Jennifer Verta

Celebrating top legal professionals in South America and the Caribbean.

Flags of Puerto Rico, Chile, Colombia, and Peru, representing countries featured in the Best Lawyers

Unveiling the 2025 Best Lawyers Editions in Brazil, Mexico, Portugal and South Africa


by Jennifer Verta

Best Lawyers celebrates the finest in law, reaffirming its commitment to the global legal community.

Flags of Brazil, Mexico, Portugal and South Africa, representing Best Lawyers countries

Announcing the 13th Edition of Best Lawyers Rankings in the United Kingdom


by Best Lawyers

Best Lawyers is proud to announce the newest edition of legal rankings in the United Kingdom, marking the 13th consecutive edition of awards in the country.

British flag in front of country's outline

Discover The Best Lawyers in Spain 2025 Edition


by Jennifer Verta

Highlighting Spain’s leading legal professionals and rising talents.

Flags of Spain, representing Best Lawyers country

Prop 36 California 2024: California’s Path to Stricter Sentencing and Criminal Justice Reform


by Jennifer Verta

Explore how Prop 36 could shape California's sentencing laws and justice reform.

Illustrated Hands Breaking Chains Against a Bright Red Background

Announcing the 16th Edition of the Best Lawyers in Germany Rankings


by Best Lawyers

Best Lawyers announces the 16th edition of The Best Lawyers in Germany™, featuring a unique set of rankings that highlights Germany's top legal talent.

German flag in front of country's outline

Celebrating Excellence in Law: 11th Edition of Best Lawyers in Italy™


by Best Lawyers

Best Lawyers announces the 11th edition of The Best Lawyers in Italy™, which features an elite list of awards showcasing Italy's current legal talent.

Italian flag in front of country's outline

Tampa Appeals Court ‘Sends Clear Message,” Ensuring School Tax Referendum Stays on Ballot


by Gregory Sirico

Hillsborough County's tax referendum is back on the 2024 ballot, promising $177 million for schools and empowering residents to decide the future of education.

Graduation cap in air surrounded by pencils and money

Find the Best Lawyers for Your Needs


by Jennifer Verta

Discover how Best Lawyers simplifies the attorney search process.

A focused woman with dark hair wearing a green top and beige blazer, working on a tablet in a dimly

Key Developments and Trends in U.S. Commercial Litigation


by Justin Smulison

Whether it's multibillion-dollar water cleanliness verdicts or college athletes vying for the right to compensation, the state of litigation remains strong.

Basketball sits in front of stacks of money

Woman on a Mission


by Rebecca Blackwell

Baker Botts partner and intellectual property chair Christa Brown-Sanford discusses how she juggles work, personal life, being a mentor and leadership duties.

Woman in green dress crossing her arms and posing for headshot

Best Lawyers Celebrates Women in the Law: Ninth Edition


by Alliccia Odeyemi

Released in both print and digital form, Best Lawyers Ninth Edition of Women in the Law features stories of inspiring leadership and timely legal issues.

Lawyer in green dress stands with hands on table and cityscape in background

The Human Cost


by Justin Smulison

2 new EU laws aim to reshape global business by enforcing ethical supply chains, focusing on human rights and sustainability

Worker wearing hat stands in field carrying equipemtn