Insight

Understanding the Constitutionality of Patent Law

Ideas can be stolen, just like the machines or products they were used to create.

Why Patents Lead to Innovation
JP

John Powers

September 26, 2018 03:56 PM

Innovation occurs when there are problems to be solved. For example, cars may be improved because they are not fuel efficient. Of course, making cars more fuel efficient is not easy; it requires energy, which in this sense is the time and hard work involved in developing innovative solutions. Time and hard work are not free, nor should they be free. This is why cars that are more fuel-efficient cost more money to make and more money to buy.

So, how does this relate to the patent process? Just as a machine or other invention can be physically stolen, so can the energy that goes into developing it. To protect against such theft, Congress holds the power “to promote the progress of science and useful arts, by securing for limited times to authors and inventors the exclusive right to their respective writings and discoveries.”

A patent is a specific property right created from this clause of the U.S. Constitution that protects the energy expended to create a new invention. In the example above, an inventor must use energy to invent a new mechanism to improve fuel economy in cars. Without patents, the inventor and the business world in which the inventor competes will both be able to build cars with the new mechanism. All else being the same, it is the inventor alone who is left with less total energy than before the new mechanism was invented. Because systems that use energy need to receive equal energy in order to continue functioning properly, the inventor must receive just compensation if he is going to be motivated to ever invent again. Acquiring a patent on an invention gives the inventor the exclusive right to make use of the invention for a limited time in exchange for disclosing the invention to society. The exclusive right compensates the inventor for the energy used to invent. Because the right is limited to a fixed period of time, and because society is provided with the disclosure of the invention, society will be able to make use of the invention without restriction once the inventor’s period of exclusivity expires. As a result, the patent benefits society by enabling innovation to persevere.

Distribution and Innovation

On the other hand, certain instances may exist where a free distribution of technology, rather than via a mechanism such as a patent, could result in the flourishing of innovation. For example, in the early 1970s, AT&T made decisions on how to provide those outside of its organization with its Uniplexed Information and Computing Service (“Unix”) operating systems. Specifically, AT&T decided to provide Unix to a number of researchers at no cost, though without permission to redistribute or to distribute modified versions. Arguably, this allowed users to collaborate with one another and improve upon many different aspects of the initial Unix operating systems. Many assert that by using these unorthodox policies, AT&T may have enabled innovation to persevere, and by increasing more widespread adoption of the Unix operating systems, also made a shrewd business move.

More typically, however, patents are seen as encouraging innovation. Elihu Thomson, who was listed as an inventor on hundreds of patents in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, and who founded a number of major electrical companies, summed up the more accepted view on the importance of patents. He said, “Shall an invention be patented or donated to the public freely? I have known some well-meaning scientific men to look askance at the patenting of inventions, as if it were a rather selfish and ungracious act, essentially unworthy. The answer is very simple. Publish an invention freely, and it will almost surely die from lack of interest in its development. It will not be developed and the world will not be benefited. Patent it, and if valuable, it will be taken up and developed into a business.”

---------------

An experienced patent attorney, John P. Powers has a solid track record of success with technology companies in acquiring patent rights for their inventions and, when needed, provides litigation support. His practice at Eckert Seamans Cherin & Mellott covers a wide variety of technologies including electrical switching apparatuses, medical devices such as respiratory therapy devices and therapeutic ultrasound technology, pharmaceutical packaging, machine tooling and related systems, and toys. Powers earned his B.S. in mechanical engineering from the University of Michigan and his J.D. from the University of Toledo College of Law.

Related Articles

Anna Inventing: The Importance of Diversity in Innovation


by Emily C. Peyser

A patent from 1887 by female inventor Anna Connelly not only revolutionized fire safety, but highlighted the need for diversity in innovation. Our world is facing big problems that need diverse voices at the table to find solutions that work for everyone. Building diverse teams and encouraging diversity in innovation is a beneficial step forward in resolving our collective challenges.

Diversity in Innovation and Technology

Forging Bonds, Building Business


by Lizl Leonardo and Crystal L. Howard

As disorienting and occasionally frightening as the pandemic has been, it has also forced lawyers to find innovative new ways to stay connected and do business.

Pandemic Sparks Innovative Ways of Conducting

Learn How to Value Your Company's IP Portfolio as a Source of Income with Patent Scorecarding


by Troy A. Groetken

It’s imperative that intellectual property counsel, especially those responsible for the protection of innovation in the electrical, chemical, pharmaceutical and life-science arenas, regularly audit their company’s IP portfolio. Here’s the best way to do it.

Intellectual Property Scorecarding Benefits

What Do Your Clients Want, Anyway?


by Emilia Levisay

Law Firm Strategies to Best Serve Clients.

Sticky notes on black chalk board that says quality, cost, and efficiency

How This Firm Is Shaping the Economic Future of Ukraine


by Best Lawyers

Denis Lysenko discusses how AEQUO has helped build a new business environment.

An Interview With AEQUO

An Interview With Norton Rose Fulbright


by Best Lawyers

Australia’s 2020 “Law Firm of the Year” in Insolvency and Reorganization Law

An Interview With Norton Rose Fulbright

The Argument Against Self-Representation in Patent Cases


by John Powers

A look back at the 1983 Nilssen case, and what it means for patent law today.

Do I Need a Lawyer to File a Patent?

Responsive Initiative


by Deborah Epstein Henry

A Fresh Twist on Innovation

Responsive Initiative

Trending Articles

Introducing the 2026 Best Lawyers Awards in Australia, Japan, New Zealand and Singapore


by Jennifer Verta

This year’s awards reflect the strength of the Best Lawyers network and its role in elevating legal talent worldwide.

2026 Best Lawyers Awards in Australia, Japan, New Zealand and Singapore

Revealing the 2026 Best Lawyers Awards in Germany, France, Switzerland and Austria


by Jamilla Tabbara

These honors underscore the reach of the Best Lawyers network and its focus on top legal talent.

map of Germany, France, Switzerland and Austria

Effective Communication: A Conversation with Jefferson Fisher


by Jamilla Tabbara

The power of effective communication beyond the law.

 Image of Jefferson Fisher and Phillip Greer engaged in a conversation about effective communication

The 2025 Legal Outlook Survey Results Are In


by Jennifer Verta

Discover what Best Lawyers honorees see ahead for the legal industry.

Person standing at a crossroads with multiple intersecting paths and a signpost.

The Best Lawyers Network: Global Recognition with Long-term Value


by Jamilla Tabbara

Learn how Best Lawyers' peer-review process helps recognized lawyers attract more clients and referral opportunities.

Lawyers networking

Jefferson Fisher: The Secrets to Influential Legal Marketing


by Jennifer Verta

How lawyers can apply Jefferson Fisher’s communication and marketing strategies to build trust, attract clients and grow their practice.

Portrait of Jefferson Fisher a legal marketing expert

Is Your Law Firm’s Website Driving Clients Away?


by Jamilla Tabbara

Identify key website issues that may be affecting client engagement and retention.

Phone displaying 'This site cannot be reached' message

A Guide to Workers' Compensation Law for 2025 and Beyond


by Bryan Driscoll

A woman with a laptop screen reflected in her glasses

Medical Malpractice Reform Trends in Texas, Utah, Georgia and SC


by Bryan Driscoll

A fresh wave of medical malpractice reform is reshaping the law.

Medical Malpractice Reform Trends hed

Why Jack Dorsey and Elon Musk Want to 'Delete All IP Law'


by Bryan Driscoll

This Isn’t Just a Debate Over How to Pay Creators. It’s a Direct Challenge to Legal Infrastructure.

Elon Musk and Jack Dorsey standing together Infront of the X logo

Best Lawyers Launches CMO Advisory Board


by Jamilla Tabbara

Strategic counsel from legal marketing’s most experienced voices.

Group photo of Best Lawyers CMO Advisory Board members

Changes in California Employment Law for 2025


by Laurie Villanueva

What employers need to know to ensure compliance in the coming year and beyond

A pair of hands holding a checklist featuring a generic profile picture and the state of California

Common Law Firm Landing Page Problems to Address


by Jamilla Tabbara

Identify key issues on law firm landing pages to improve client engagement and conversion.

Laptop showing law firm landing page analytics

New Employment Law Recognizes Extraordinary Stress Is Everyday Reality for NY Lawyers


by Bryan Driscoll

A stressed woman has her head resting on her hands above a laptop

Best Lawyers Introduces Smithy AI


by Jamilla Tabbara

Transforming legal content creation for attorneys and firms.

Start using Smithy AI, a content tool by Best Lawyers

How to Create High-Converting Landing Pages for Your Law Firm


by Jamilla Tabbara

Learn how to create high-converting law firm landing pages that drive client engagement and lead generation.

Laptop screen displaying website tools to improve client conversion rates