Insight

The Courtroom Climate

Recent decisions across Canada have underscored that courts are wary of usurping legislatures—both provincial and federal—when faced with litigants demanding they do something about climate change.

Factory image with courtroom imagery overlaid
PK

Written by Peter Kolla

Published: September 28, 2023

The United Nations Environment Programme recently reported that the number of climate-related lawsuits worldwide has more than doubled over the last five years. Canada is contributing to this trend, with the sixth-highest number of climate litigation cases globally. These suits have primarily targeted governments both federally and provincially. However, despite the various claims alleged and the statements in court decisions about the importance of addressing climate change, Canadian courts have consistently demonstrated clear limits on their ability to do so.

Non-Justiciable Cases

“Justiciability” is the legal doctrine that applies when the subject of a case or the relief sought is too political in nature to be properly adjudicated by the courts. Claims that are not justiciable can be struck—a move that recognizes the separation of powers between courts and legislatures.

In Misdzi Yikh v. Canada, for example, two hereditary chiefs of a British Columbia First Nation claimed the federal government had breached the common law and Constitution in failing to legislate to combat climate change. They sought wide-ranging relief, including an order requiring the federal government to amend its environmental assessment statutes to allow it to cancel approval of high-greenhouse-gas (GHG)-emitting projects. The Federal Court struck the claim in 2020 on the basis that it was not justiciable, noting that “[i]t is hard to imagine a more political issue than climate change.”

Similarly, in Environnement Jeunesse c. Procureur Général du Canada, the Quebec Court of Appeal in 2021 held that a proposed class action brought by a youth nonprofit organization against the federal government was non-justiciable. The nonprofit alleged that the government’s failure to implement measures to limit global warming was violating the fundamental rights of young people; it sought an order requiring the government to implement those measures.

While noting that no one questions the urgency of acting to mitigate climate change, the Quebec Court of Appeal nonetheless held that the remedy sought would in effect force Parliament to act without indicating how it should do so, holding as well that deference by the courts was required given that Parliament is better placed to weigh the innumerable challenges of global warming.

Cases in Which Relief Was Denied

Even when finding cases justiciable, courts have sometimes denied the relief sought. The Ontario Superior Court of Justice’s 2023 decision in Mathur v. Ontario dismissed a lawsuit brought by seven Ontario youth. The suit claimed that provincial legislation that lowered emissions targets, and plans for reducing GHG emissions, were not stringent enough to combat climate change, thereby infringing the applicants’ Constitutional Charter rights.

The Federal Court struck the claim in 2020 on the basis that it was not justiciable, noting that '[i]t is hard to imagine a more political issue than climate change.'"

They sought, among other things, an order requiring the Ontario government to “set a science-based GHG reduction target.” The Ontario Superior Court rejected their argument that the provincial government’s legislation adopting a more lenient target for GHG emission reductions was unconstitutional, holding that a “mere change in the law cannot be the basis for a Charter violation.” It characterized the applicants’ claims as alleging the government was not doing enough to protect their Constitutional rights but held that they had not demonstrated that any deprivation was contrary to the principles of fundamental justice.

The court also, however, rejected the Ontario government’s argument that there was no causal connection between its target for reducing GHG emissions and mitigating the effects of climate change. It found that by not taking steps to further reduce the province’s emissions, the government was contributing to an increase in the risk of death, and that while Ontario’s contribution to global warming “may be numerically small, it is real, measurable and not speculative.”

British Columbia’s Supreme Court, in Sierra Club of British Columbia Foundation v. British Columbia (Minister of Environment and Climate Change Strategy), considered provincial legislation that set GHG emissions targets and imposed a statutory obligation on the BC government to prepare an annual “climate accountability” report. The court held in 2023 that the provincial government had complied with the legislation and dismissed the suit—while also noting that if the BC government were required to disclose the information requested, it might have contributed to the province meeting some of its emissions goals “in a break from the consistent history of missing its targets.”

The Federal Court’s 2023 decision in Sierra Club Canada Foundation v. Canada (Environment and Climate Change) rejected a challenge to the federal minister of environment and climate change’s approval of the Bay du Nord oil development project offshore of Newfoundland and Labrador. Two environmental nonprofits and one representing eight Mi’gmaq communities in New Brunswick claimed the minister improperly failed to consider the effects of GHG emissions downstream from Bay du Nord. Downstream emissions are generated by the crude oil recovered from the project and subsequently used by others.

The court held that Canadian regulators have repeatedly found that downstream emissions need not be considered in environmental assessments, and those decisions have been upheld on appeal or review. It also cited authority holding that nothing in the relevant environmental assessment legislation required a consideration of general issues such as climate change in making a decision mandated by the legislation, noting further that the oil from Bay du Nord could be used all over the world for many purposes, which might result in different emissions levels. It would be impossible to determine how much downstream use, if any, would be within Canada. Accordingly, considering the environmental effects of downstream emissions would be speculative, and it was therefore reasonable for the assessment of the Bay du Nord project to exclude them.

Closing Considerations

To date, litigants in Canada have not successfully challenged alleged government action or inaction on matters related to climate change. Nonetheless, many people continue to look for ways to impose responsibility and to require governments to take more robust action to mitigate it.


Headline Image: Adobestock/Aurélien Pottier, MIND AND I Perilous Times: iStock/Baona
Learn More About:

Resources For Lawyers

Related Articles

The Credibility Problem in AI Legal Search


by Bryan Driscoll

A fluent answer can make a lawyer recommendation look settled. Credibility depends on what supports it, not on how well it reads.

Blue digital wireframe of binoculars

AI Legal Search Is Moving From Keywords to Intent


by Bryan Driscoll

People can now describe a legal problem in ordinary words. The harder work is reading what they need and turning it into a pathway.

A digital search bar icon surrounded by colorful magnifying glasses on a light blue background.

Why Third-Party Validation Matters More in AI Search


by Bryan Driscoll

Much of what AI-assisted tools read about your practice sits on pages you did not write. Here is what makes an outside source credible.

A person interacting with a laptop and selecting a digital profile icon hovering over a global map.

How to Optimize Your Best Lawyers Profile for AI Search


by Everett Sizemore

Learn how a complete, well-structured Best Lawyers profile can strengthen your visibility and accuracy across AI search platforms.

A laptop screen displaying the Best Lawyers profile dashboard showing customizable sections.

How to Make Legal Content Easier for AI Search to Read


by Bryan Driscoll

Your best analysis is only as useful as the page it sits on. What to fix so clients, search engines and AI tools can all read it.

A magnifying glass analyzing digital files and documents to illustrate structured content formatting

How AI Is Changing the Way Clients Find Lawyers


by Jamilla Tabbara

Best Lawyers CEO Phil Greer explains how AI-driven search tools are reshaping legal marketing and why credibility markers matter.

AI chat bubble icon with stars representing artificial intelligence transforming client-lawyer conne

How to Vote with Best Lawyers


by Jamilla Tabbara and Kimberly Welsh

Guidance for participating in the peer-reviewed voting process.

Golden figures of people standing on blue surface connected by white lines

Why Original Profiles Matter in Legal Marketing


by Jamilla Tabbara

How original, up-to-date profiles improve visibility and client trust.

Multiple web browser windows displaying lawyer profile pages

10 Benefits of a Complete Best Lawyers Profile


by Jamilla Tabbara

This guide outlines the key ways a complete profile can enhance visibility and attract prospective clients.

SEO letters with gears and magnifying glass representing search engine optimization

Do Backlinks Still Help SEO?


by Everett Sizemore

What Changed with AI, and What I Didn't

Two interconnected website cards with arrows showing link relationship between web pages

AI Tools for Lawyers: How Smithy AI Solves Key Challenges


by Jamilla Tabbara

Understand the features and benefits within the Best Lawyers Digital Marketing Platform.

Legal professional editing profile content with Smithy AI

Build Your Legal Practice with Effective Online Networking


by Jamilla Tabbara

How thoughtful online networking supports sustained legal practice growth.

Abstract web of connected figures symbolizing online networking among legal professionals

Blogging for Law Firms: Turning Content into Client Connections


by Jennifer Verta

How law firms use blogs to earn trust and win clients.

Lawyer typing blog content on laptop in office

Law Firm Marketing ROI: Strategies for Small and Midsize Firms


by Jamilla Tabbara

Understand how to improve your marketing ROI with methods tailored for law firms.

3D Computer with Icons Representing ROI Tools and Metrics

Law Firm Marketing: 5 Strategic Steps to Attract More Clients


by Jamilla Tabbara

A practical framework for marketing a law firm with purpose.

Light bulb above a chalkboard illustrating strategic ideas

Best Lawyers Introduces Smithy AI


by Jamilla Tabbara

Transforming legal content creation for attorneys and firms.

Start using Smithy AI, a content tool by Best Lawyers

Trending Articles

What AI Visibility Means for Lawyers


by Bryan Driscoll and Josh Rupall

AI tools increasingly interpret lawyers public information. Clear, consistent and credible sources help ensure they describe legal expertise accurately.

AI dashboard visualizing a lawyer's online profile, reputation, and practice information across mult

The Best Lawyers in Canada 2027: Recognizing the Nation's Top Legal Talent


by Jamilla Tabbara

Honoring established leaders and rising practitioners across Canada's legal profession.

3D model of Canada textured with the Canadian flag.

2027 Best Lawyers Awards: Honoring Excellence in the Legal Profession


by Jamilla Tabbara

Recognizing the outstanding attorneys leading top practice areas nationwide.

United States with American flag representing The Best Lawyers in America 2027 awards

2027 Best Lawyers Awards in Brazil, Mexico, Portugal and Spain


by Jamilla Tabbara

Explore key findings from the awards, including recognition figures and emerging legal talent.

3D country maps of Brazil, Mexico, Portugal and Spain with national flags

Announcing the 2027 Best Lawyers Awards: Austria, Germany and Switzerland


by Jamilla Tabbara

Celebrating the legal professionals throughout Central Europe.

Graphic displaying three-dimensional map cutouts of Austria, Germany and Switzerland.

The Best Lawyers in France 2027: Peer-Reviewed Excellence


by Jamilla Tabbara

Seventeen editions of peer trust, a growing profession and a dynamic legal market.

3D Map of France with National Flag Graphic

Who Can Override a Power of Attorney?


by Bryan Driscoll

A power of attorney carries real legal authority, but it isn't absolute. Here's who can step in to revoke, restrict or set it aside.

Close-up of a power of attorney document, symbolizing legal authority, revocation rights, guardiansh

Inside the 2027 Best Lawyers Awards in Chile, Colombia and Puerto Rico


by Jamilla Tabbara

A closer look at the research process, methodology and key statistics behind the 2027 editions.

3D map cutouts of Chile, Colombia, and Puerto Rico

How to Get an Eviction Off Your Record


by Bryan Driscoll

Whether an eviction can be removed, sealed or corrected depends on your state, your case and where the record appears.

A printed eviction notice attached to a decorative metal security gate, representing housing instabi

How Peer Review Works: Best Lawyers Methodology Explained


by Jamilla Tabbara

Understanding the independent, data-driven framework that defines professional legal standing.

A glowing professional icon surrounded by incoming arrows, symbolizing data collection and feedback.

Google Is Losing Major Antitrust Cases. Is This the End of Big Tech’s Winning Streak?


by Justin Smulison

Legal experts say the remedies and appeals, not the liability findings, will determine if Google's losses reshape the tech industry.

Google Antitrust Losses: What They Mean for Big Tech

How to Optimize Your Best Lawyers Profile for AI Search


by Everett Sizemore

Learn how a complete, well-structured Best Lawyers profile can strengthen your visibility and accuracy across AI search platforms.

A laptop screen displaying the Best Lawyers profile dashboard showing customizable sections.

What Is a Hostile Work Environment?


by Bryan Driscoll

Not every difficult job is a hostile work environment in the eyes of the law. Here's how to tell the difference and what to do next.

Blurred image of a distressed employee in an office, surrounded by motion-blurred coworkers, conveyi

Can You Sue Someone for Emotional Distress?


by Bryan Driscoll

Emotional distress can sometimes support a lawsuit, but whether you have a valid claim depends on the facts, the law and your ability to prove real harm.

Abstract black-and-white face with multiple screaming mouths, representing emotional distress, anxie

GEO for Law Firms: What It Is and How to Optimize for AI Search


by Bryan Driscoll and Everett Sizemore

A seven-step audit for law firms that covers the terms, the pages, the outside profiles and what you can actually measure.

Hands typing on a laptop with glowing GEO and AI search graphics

What Is the Downside of Filing for Bankruptcy?


by Bryan Driscoll

A balanced look at the credit, financial and emotional costs of bankruptcy and when filing still makes sense.

A close-up photograph of a weathered, empty red leather wallet lying abandoned.
Tap to expand

Welcome to Smithy AI the Best Lawyers Assistant

I can help you find attorneys, compare firms, explore practice areas, and surface rankings curated from the Best Lawyers methodology.

Not legal advice This assistant provides general information only. For guidance on your specific situation, please consult a licensed attorney.
Learn about Best Lawyers Research Process
Suggested prompts
Chat limit reached
You've reached the message limit for this chat. To keep exploring, browse Best Lawyers directly or come back later to start a fresh conversation.
Browse Best Lawyers