Insight

“But I Can’t Prove It.” Yes You Can, With Circumstantial Evidence

“But I Can’t Prove It.” Yes You Can, With Circumstantial Evidence

Brian J. MacDonough

Brian J. MacDonough

March 15, 2019 04:53 PM

By David I. Brody and Jaclyn N. McNeely

It is impossible to count the number of times we have heard an employee say, “I know something is wrong but I can’t prove it.” Our response is to say, “That is what we do.” If something is wrong, we help you prove it using what evidence is available, which is often what lawyers call circumstantial evidence – the circumstances which, if looked at as a whole, will show a jury what is really going on. To illustrate, we are going to look at proof of a discrimination claim – but proof of many employment claims (whistleblowing, retaliation, etc.), not just discrimination, can be made by circumstantial evidence.

The Elements of a Discrimination Claim

Employment discrimination in the most literal sense is favoring (or disfavoring) one employee over another. Employment discrimination becomes unlawful when the basis of the favoritism is a forbidden characteristic – what the law calls membership in a protected class: race, color, religion, national origin, sex, gender identity, sexual orientation, handicap, etc. To prove unlawful employment discrimination, you must show four things:

  1. Membership in a protected class;
  2. An adverse employment action – (for more on this, click here);
  3. Discriminatory animus; and
  4. Causation.

The last two elements are often the hardest to prove by direct evidence, e.g., by an employer saying something like, “I am firing you because you are too old to do this job.” Instead, employees prove their cases by, as one court put it, presenting the jury a “convincing mosaic of circumstantial evidence [which] shows that discrimination has occurred.”

The Convincing Mosaic

Often times, the reason your employer gives you for an adverse employment action just doesn’t make sense. For example, your employer tells you that you didn’t get a promotion because “you don’t have enough experience managing others,” but then you learn that the person selected has never before been a supervisor. Such “weaknesses, implausibilities, inconsistencies, incoherencies, or contradictions in the employer’s…reason for its action” may be used as circumstantial evidence to show that the employer’s stated reason for its decision is not the real reason. Similarly, if your employer gives you a reason which you know to be false, that evidence can be used to prove that the real reason was unlawful discrimination.

Other times employers apply unlawful stereotypes. Maybe you are a female executive whose employer refused to put you on the senior leadership team because you were “too aggressive” towards subordinates, or “not nice enough” to colleagues. Or maybe you are an ethnic minority who has received a negative review citing your “lack of deference” to others – or, in other words, that you did not “know your place.”

Sometimes timing can serve as circumstantial evidence. For example, a successful woman who receives her first critical evaluation shortly after disclosing her pregnancy, or a 55 year old employee with an exemplary record who suddenly starts getting written up by a new, younger manager.

Excessive subjectivity in the reason can also be circumstantial evidence of unlawful discrimination. Take, for example, the sales executive who has surpassed all of his sales targets, but sees his bonus reduced for not showing “hustle” or not being a “team player.”

The above are just a few examples. Courts recognize all sorts of circumstantial evidence may contribute to the “convincing mosaic”:

  • Shifting rationales – an employer gives different reasons at different times;
  • Disparate treatment – others outside the protected class are treated more favorably;
  • Discriminatory remarks – comments by a decision maker can be a “window into his state of mind”;
  • Negative treatment of others – others in the same protected class are also mistreated;
  • Statistics / workforce composition – e.g., the upper ranks of a company are closed off to a member of certain protected class, or the majority of those selected for layoff are in the same protected class;
  • Deviation from practice / policy – e.g., others outside the protected class are given a chance to fix a problem, or there is a progressive discipline policy that is ignored;
  • Failure to document – e.g., being fired for alleged poor performance, but without supporting documentation.

Conclusion

The key take-away is that few cases have the so-called “smoking gun” evidence of unlawful motive, but by looking at all of the circumstances – the whole picture – you may be able establish your claim. If you believe you are being subjected to discrimination or other wrongful treatment in the workplace, consult an employment attorney as soon as possible.

To read more visit Sherin & Lodgen https://www.sherin.com/employment-blog/2019/03/11/but-i-cant-prove-it-yes-you-can-with-circumstantial-evidence/

Related Articles

Phoning It In


by Alyson M. St. Pierre, Ashley C. Pack and Crystal S. Wildeman

It’s not easy for employers to weigh requests from employees to work from afar, even in the wake of the pandemic. Considerations include COVID-19, vaccinations, the Americans with Disabilities Act and the nature of the job itself.

Employer Considerations for Teleworking

Compelled to Compete


by Ashish Mahendru

Courts and legislatures—and now the White House—are taking an increasingly dim view of noncompete employment agreements, a development the pandemic has quickened. What can employers do to protect their confidential information?

Protection for Employers Beyond Noncompetes

Look Out Below


by Mary Jo Larson

Employee 401(k) and other pension plans that include company stock can be a financial minefield. What’s a responsible fiduciary to do to lessen the risk of a plummeting share price—and the risk of a subsequent “stock-drop” lawsuit from aggrieved workers?

Navigating Employee 401(k) and Pension Plans

Can Employers Legally Require Their Employees to Get a COVID-19 Vaccine?


by Candace E. Johnson

With the COVID-19 vaccine more widely available now, many employers are asking if they can require employees to receive the vaccine and what risks are involved in doing so.

Can Employers Legally Require Vaccines?

Evolving Marijuana Laws and the Workplace


by Tess P. Anglin

How can employers enforce statutes that differ from state to state?

Red image of a marijuana leaf

Employers Must Soon Use Yet Another New I-9 Form


by Fisher Phillips

New document could be liability trap for unsuspecting employers.

Begin Using the New Form Now

The Other Shoe Drops—The NLRB’s “Contingent Workforce” Activism Continues


by Timothy C. Kamin

The NLRB will now permit a single bargaining unit to include employees who are solely employed by an employer along with other employees who are jointly employed by that employer and a staffing provider, all without the consent of either employer.

Employee Activism

Paid Leave


by Best Lawyers

Eight attorneys from across the country weigh in.

Paid Leave

Millennials


by Joanna Barsh, Lauren Brown, and Kayvan Kian

Burden, blessing, or both?

Millennials

Trending Articles

How Palworld Is Testing the Limits of Nintendo’s Legal Power


by Gregory Sirico

Many are calling the new game Palworld “Pokémon GO with guns,” noting the games striking similarities. Experts speculate how Nintendo could take legal action.

Animated figures with guns stand on top of creatures

Announcing the 2023 The Best Lawyers in America Honorees


by Best Lawyers

Only the top 5.3% of all practicing lawyers in the U.S. were selected by their peers for inclusion in the 29th edition of The Best Lawyers in America®.

Gold strings and dots connecting to form US map

The U.S. Best Lawyers Voting Season Is Open


by Best Lawyers

The voting season for the 31st edition of The Best Lawyers in America® and the 5th edition of Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch® in America is officially underway, and we are offering some helpful advice to this year’s voters.

Golden figures of people standing on blue surface connected by white lines

How To Find A Pro Bono Lawyer


by Best Lawyers

Best Lawyers dives into the vital role pro bono lawyers play in ensuring access to justice for all and the transformative impact they have on communities.

Hands joined around a table with phone, paper, pen and glasses

Announcing the 2022 Best Lawyers® in the United States


by Best Lawyers

The results include an elite field of top lawyers listed in the 28th Edition of The Best Lawyers in America® and in the 2nd Edition of Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch in America for 2022.

2022 Best Lawyers Listings for United States

2021 Best Lawyers: The Global Issue


by Best Lawyers

The 2021 Global Issue features top legal talent from the most recent editions of Best Lawyers and Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch worldwide.

2021 Best Lawyers: The Global Issue

What the Courts Say About Recording in the Classroom


by Christina Henagen Peer and Peter Zawadski

Students and parents are increasingly asking to use audio devices to record what's being said in the classroom. But is it legal? A recent ruling offer gives the answer to a question confusing parents and administrators alike.

Is It Legal for Students to Record Teachers?

Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch in America for 2023


by Best Lawyers

The third edition of Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch in America™ highlights the legal talent of lawyers who have been in practice less than 10 years.

Three arrows made of lines and dots on blue background

The Best Lawyers in Australia™ 2024 Launch


by Best Lawyers

Best Lawyers is excited to announce The Best Lawyers in Australia™ for 2023, including the top lawyers and law firms from Australia.

Australian Parliament beside water at sunset

The Upcycle Conundrum


by Karen Kreider Gaunt

Laudable or litigious? What you need to know about potential copyright and trademark infringement when repurposing products.

Repurposed Products and Copyright Infringemen

Inflation Escalation


by Ashley S. Wagner

Inflation and rising costs are at the forefront of everyone’s mind as we enter 2023. The current volatile market makes it more important than ever to understand the rent escalation clauses in current and future commercial lease agreements.

Suited figure in front of rising market and inflated balloon

Wage and Overtime Laws for Truck Drivers


by Greg Mansell

For truck drivers nationwide, underpayment and overtime violations are just the beginning of a long list of problems. Below we explore the wages you are entitled to but may not be receiving.

Truck Driver Wage and Overtime Laws in the US

A Celebration of Excellence: The Best Lawyers in Canada 2024 Awards


by Best Lawyers

As we embark on the 18th edition of The Best Lawyers in Canada™, we are excited to highlight excellence and top legal talent across the country.

Abstract image of red and white Canada flag in triangles

Announcing The Best Lawyers in South Africa™ 2024


by Best Lawyers

Best Lawyers is excited to announce the landmark 15th edition of The Best Lawyers in South Africa™ for 2024, including the exclusive "Law Firm of the Year" awards.

Sky view of South Africa town and waterways

Best Lawyers Voting Is Now Open


by Best Lawyers

Voting has begun in several countries across the globe, including the United States, the United Kingdom and Europe. Below we offer dates, details and answers to voting-related questions to assist with the voting process.

Hands holding smartphone with five stars above phone

8 Different Types of Criminal Defenses in Law


by Best Lawyers

Learn about the different types of criminal defenses available in law, including innocence, self-defense, insanity and more. Protect your rights today.

Silver handcuffs laying on finger printed papers