On Neutral Ground

Years after the American Bar Association resolution on diversifying the pool of neutrals, alternative dispute resolution panels still fall short.

ADR Panels Still Fall Short in Diversity
Patricia Brown Holmes

Patricia Brown Holmes and Rachel F. Sifuentes

October 4, 2021 03:00 PM

This article originally appeared in the 2022 Best Lawyers in the Midwest publication on October 1, 2022.

In the overall push to bring greater diversity, equity and inclusion (DEI) to the legal industry, one sector of our field receives relatively little attention: the alternative dispute resolution (ADR) process and the neutrals—mediators and arbitrators—who help parties resolve disputes outside the court system. As more and more matters are resolved through ADR rather than traditional litigation, now is the time to reap the benefits of increased diversity and inclusion among neutrals.

It is difficult to come by accurate data about the state of representation on ADR panels because of the confidential nature of these proceedings, but we do have some. According to a analysis of more than 350 neutrals affiliated with one of the nation’s largest providers of dispute resolution services, Judicial Arbitration and Mediation Services (JAMS), 25% are women and 7% are racial minorities. We do not have data about the disability, LGBTQ+, military veteran or language status of neutrals in that cohort, but we know that these additional aspects of diversity are just as important to consider in efforts of inclusion, as are race and gender.

Unlike in traditional litigation, parties using private dispute resolution have choices in the arbitrators who will mediate their dispute, and many claimants have good reasons to choose neutrals who are open to understanding their background and life experiences. Viewed through the lens of representation alone, it appears that the diversity they seek is difficult to find in the pool of available neutrals. What’s more, in cases where binding arbitration clauses mandate that claimants engage in the ADR process, parties from underrepresented backgrounds may find that the current mostly homogenous pool of neutrals may put them at a disadvantage in negotiations.

Diversifying the pool of neutrals is the first essential step to improving inclusion in the mediation and arbitration processes. Neutrals from underrepresented backgrounds may be better positioned to help in the following ways:

1. BUILDING TRUST. Productive dispute resolution depends on the willingness of both parties to share key information with the neutral mediating the dispute. Trust—in both the neutral and in the dispute resolution process itself—means that all parties feel their perspective and experiences will be understood and that the neutral will approach all parties in the process with an open, inclusive mindset. Ideally, neutrals should be knowledgeable not just about the details of the dispute but about the broader context in which it is taking place. For example, consider a case alleging that packaging representations on a multicultural product are misleading to consumers. The parties in that matter may be more willing to trust a mediator who is familiar with the life experiences of the ethnic community involved in the situation, as much as they understand the legalities of the matter. That trust will lead to better communication and a sense that both parties are on a level playing field, with a neutral who is invested in truly understanding both sides of the story.

Neutrals who have experienced or are aware of the varieties of backgrounds that come into play in an ADR setting can be more sensitive to the nuances of communication and better prepared to navigate cultural differences that impact negotiations.”

2. COMMUNICATE ACROSS DIFFERENCE. Communication is a complex act, and our upbringing, cultural values, life experiences and relationships to power structures impact what we say and how we say it. Neutrals who have experienced or are aware of the varieties of backgrounds that come into play in an ADR setting can be more sensitive to the nuances of communication—styles of talking as well as body language—and better prepared to navigate cultural differences that impact negotiations. For instance, in some cultures, interrupting in conversation is not considered rude but instead signifies a kind of “active listening” and participation. Conversely, the passive listening considered polite in some circles may read as a lack of interest or attention. Some cultures view maintaining eye contact as a sign of respect and will distrust people who will not look them in the eye. In other cultures, restraint and stoicism are the highest value, and prolonged eye contact is not seen as appropriate and may be interpreted as unnecessarily aggressive. These norms also vary across generation and gender. A neutral who is familiar with and aware of varying communication styles can avoid missteps like misinterpreting an active communication style as bad-faith behavior, or inappropriately correlating a party’s trustworthiness with how comfortable he or she is with eye contact. Avoiding misinterpretations like these and instead promoting openness in communications through understanding may have a significantly positive impact on the negotiation and improve rates of resolutions in ADR.

3. ANSWER THE CALL OF CLIENTS ON DEI. In the past several years, law firms have devoted more attention than ever before to issues of equity and inclusion when it comes to hiring and retention, performance assessment and promotion, staffing of client matters and more. Those efforts have been driven in no small part by clients seeking to hold their outside legal teams responsible for making progress on DEI. Clients are increasingly making the same demands for diversity, equity and inclusion in the ADR process. Raising awareness about the need for greater diversity in neutrals, and taking steps to bring about that change, provides law firms with an additional avenue for demonstrating their commitment to values of equity and inclusion to clients. Just as it is crucial for the lawyers representing a company to reflect the diversity of our society, it is also important for that diversity and inclusion to exist among the neutrals who mediate and arbitrate a company’s matters.

In its 2018 Resolution 105, the American Bar Association urged, “providers of domestic and international dispute resolution to expand their rosters with minorities, women, persons with disabilities and persons of differing sexual orientations and gender identities (‘diverse neutrals’) and to encourage the selection of diverse neutrals.” Not only are the current rosters themselves inadequate to meet the needs of parties participating in ADR, but the few available neutrals from underrepresented backgrounds are “less likely to be selected due to the network-based and confidential nature” of ADR. This lack of transparency increases the role of implicit bias in selection. In contrast, by welcoming and promoting diverse talent into the ranks of available neutrals all along the spectrum of diversity, including beyond gender and ethnicity, we have an opportunity to foster equity and inclusion in ADR panels, which are mediating disputes among parties from all walks of life.

Calling attention to the deficit of diverse neutrals in ADR is only the first step. It is certainly a hopeful sign to see the launch of new ventures such as Marcie Dickson’s Alterity, the first Black woman-owned dispute resolution firm, whose expert panel includes a diverse group of ex-judges, law firm partners and former in-house counsel. Next, stakeholders from all corners of the industry must push forward a conversation about transparency and data: If we cannot measure where we are, we cannot make progress. As Resolution 105 concludes, “Achieving real progress will not only require continued attention from providers in terms of recruiting and supporting women and minority mediators and arbitrators, but also clients who are willing to ask questions that perhaps they haven’t in the past.”

Inclusion efforts with mediators and arbitrators, such as DEI training, can also help by increasing awareness of unintentional biases, stereotyping, discrimination and differences in value systems, communication styles and cultural sensitivities. This can lead to better interactions with people from different backgrounds with different perspectives, which is the hallmark of successful conflict management and the goal of every mediation and arbitration.

The status quo in ADR does not equitably serve all parties who come to the table to resolve disputes. But change is possible, and we owe it to the people we serve to try.

At a moment when trial courts are massively backlogged and businesses are increasingly looking to resolve disputes outside the courtroom, it is essential that the ADR process has legitimacy—both legally and because the participants feel the process is justified. If employees and other claimants feel that mediation enlarges, rather than restricts, their access to justice, then ADR can live up to its potential as a simpler, more efficient route to resolving legal conflicts. Increased diversity, equity and inclusion among the pools of available neutrals for ADR panels will be a key driving force in strengthening the legitimacy of ADR in the eyes of participants.

Patricia Brown Holmes is the managing partner of Riley Safer Holmes & Cancila and focuses her practice on high-stakes commercial litigation, crisis management, white collar crime, and legal counseling. Patricia is the first African-American woman to lead and have her name on the door of a major law firm that is not women- or minority-owned.

Rachel Sifuentes is an associate at Riley Safer Holmes & Cancila. Clients in high-stakes commercial litigation, class action, intellectual property litigation, and those facing investigation by government regulators turn to her to resolve their cases.

Headline Image: iStock/Vadim Sazhniev

Related Articles

The Best Lawyers in the Midwest

by Best Lawyers

Our 2022 Best Lawyers in the Midwest Digital publication features top-ranked legal talent, including Best Lawyers and Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch in America throughout six Midwest states.

The Best Lawyers in the Midwest

Road to Somewhere

by Mark LeHocky

How can attorneys take steps to improve settlement efforts and avoid unpleasant surprises as they map out a dispute resolution? One litigator-turned-general counsel-turned mediator (with some help from a distinguished rock star) points the way forward.

Improved Dispute Resolution Settlement

Midwest "Lawyer of the Year" Honorees

by Best Lawyers

We asked our "Lawyer of the Year" recipients in the Midwest what they found most rewarding and most challenging about their fields of law. Here is what they had to say.

Midwest "Lawyer of the Year" Honorees

Midwest Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch in America

by Best Lawyers

We asked our Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch recipients throughout the Midwest what they found most rewarding and most challenging about their fields of law. Here is what they had to say.

Midwest Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch in Americ

Midwest In the Law

by Gregory Sirico

We examine five court cases that are ongoing in Illinois, Michigan, Ohio, Minnesota and Indiana.

A Look at Court Cases in the Midwest


Resolving the Toughest Cases

by Justin Smulison

Eight-time “Lawyer of the Year” Victor H. Pribanic reflects on a critical birth injury trial in 2022 and how his firm’s advocacy resonated with jurors.

Suited man with glasses poses for professional headshot

"Lawyer of the Year"

Women with blond hair and earrings poses for headshot

Nancy Rubner Frandsen

Trademark Law

Philadelphia, PA


The Impact of Plea Bargains in Criminal Cases in the U.S.

by Best Lawyers

Best Lawyers highlights why plea bargains have risen to such prevalence, quickly becoming an essential part of the criminal justice system in the U.S.

Client and attorney stand before a judge in a courtroom

A Balancing Act

by Joseph Milizio

New York State recently passed a landmark law that expands LGBTQ couples’ ability to start a family while protecting surrogates’ rights.

Surrogacy Rights for LGBTQ Couples

Fostering Acceptance

by Cassandra Biron

Those looking to be a foster or adoptive parent for LGBTQ youth must understand which kinds of support are most beneficial to parent and child alike. Happily, resources are now more widely available than ever.  

Resources for Fostering LGBTQ Youth

A Beautiful Mind: Motown Beginnings, Top Dealmaker

by Sara Collin

Motown scion Farah Fakir Cook has achieved her own stardom away from the klieg lights, helping clients navigate ever-changing currents in intellectual property and technology. One crucial topic looms especially large for her in the years ahead: How current law will contend with the rise of artificial intelligence.

Woman wearing pink suit standing against desk

Your Fault or My Fault, It All Goes Through No-Fault

by Michael L. Taub

The No-Fault System, which helps victims receive payment for accident-related medical bills, does not always regard minor accidents on court dockets.

Man at steering wheel leaning forward grasping sore neck


A Street Fight in the Bronx

by Adam Leitman Bailey

Adam Leitman Bailey’s firm helped settle a Bronx brawl over land between two parties and brought victory against a long-standing powerful family in New York.

Warehouse in New York at night

The Day-To-Day of an Immigration Lawyer in the U.S.

by Best Lawyers

In this article, Best Lawyers takes a glimpse into the day-to-day life of an immigration lawyer, what roles they must take on and how their assistance may be critical to the outcome of a case.

Two U.S. flags surround gold text and official seal


Salvi & Maher, LLP: Illinois and Wisconsin's Personal Injury Firm

by Justin Smulison

For more than 35 years, Salvi & Maher LLP has defended their clients throughout Illinois and Wisconsin in various areas of personal injury law, including medical malpractice, motor vehicle accidents, premises liability and trucking litigation.

Skyline of Chicago with green river and blue background


Emroch & Kilduff: Virginia's Personal Injury & Medical Malpractice Attorneys

by Emroch & Kilduff

For over 40 years, the award-winning Virginia-based firm Emroch & Kilduff has worked to represent their personal injury clients in both state and federal courts.

Skyline with water and bridge on blue background

Trending Articles

Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch in America for 2023

by Best Lawyers

The third edition of Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch in America™ highlights the legal talent of lawyers who have been in practice less than 10 years.

Three arrows made of lines and dots on blue background

The Best Lawyers in New Zealand™ 2024 Awards

by Best Lawyers

The Best Lawyers in New Zealand 2024 awards include an elite field of top lawyers and law firms.

Auckland, New Zealand Skyline at twilight

Presenting The Best Lawyers in Singapore™ 2024

by Best Lawyers

Best Lawyers offers the most prestigious awards for lawyers and law firms in Singapore for 2024.

Singapore skyline at night

Announcing the 2023 The Best Lawyers in America Honorees

by Best Lawyers

Only the top 5.3% of all practicing lawyers in the U.S. were selected by their peers for inclusion in the 29th edition of The Best Lawyers in America®.

Gold strings and dots connecting to form US map

The Best Lawyers in Australia™ 2024 Launch

by Best Lawyers

Best Lawyers is excited to announce The Best Lawyers in Australia™ for 2023, including the top lawyers and law firms from Australia.

Australian Parliament beside water at sunset

Announcing The Best Lawyers in Japan™ 2024

by Best Lawyers

We are proud to present the 2024 edition of Best Lawyers awards for Japan which include the top lawyers and law firms in the country.

Mt. Fuji in the background with fall leaves and structure in front


Salvi & Maher, LLP: Illinois and Wisconsin's Personal Injury Firm

by Justin Smulison

For more than 35 years, Salvi & Maher LLP has defended their clients throughout Illinois and Wisconsin in various areas of personal injury law, including medical malpractice, motor vehicle accidents, premises liability and trucking litigation.

Skyline of Chicago with green river and blue background


Athea Trial Lawyers

by Justin Smulison

Athea Trial Lawyers is a nationally recognized firm who has received record-breaking victories throughout the country on behalf of personal injury victims.

women with shades of blue in mass arrangement


Rash Mueller Knows What it Means to Help

by Jeffrey Beasley

David Rash of Rash Mueller draws from first-hand experience on the affects of tragic personal injury and loss. His Florida law firm has spent years dedicated to helping the injured find justice.

Doctor with scope reviewing brain scan on screen

The Best Lawyers in South Africa™ 2023

by Best Lawyers

Best Lawyers proudly announces lawyers recognized in South Africa for 2023.

South African flag


Mastering the Art of Trial Practice

by John Fields

With its billion-dollar track record, Morelli Law Firm has earned a reputation as one of the country's most successful trial firms.

Morelli and team at table in office with windows

Announcing The Best Lawyers in Germany™ 2023

by Best Lawyers

The results include an elite field of top lawyers and firms from Germany.

Black, red and yellow stripes

Choosing a Title Company: What a Seller Should Expect

by Roy D. Oppenheim

When it comes to choosing a title company, how much power exactly does a seller have?

Choosing the Title Company As Seller

Famous Songs Unprotected by Copyright Could Mean Royalties for Some

by Michael B. Fein

A guide to navigating copyright claims on famous songs.

Can I Sing "Happy Birthday" in Public?

The Role of a Lawyer in the Slip-and-Fall Settlement Process

by Best Lawyers

Let’s examine the role of a lawyer in the slip-and-fall settlement process and how they can help you achieve a fair and just outcome for your case.

Unseen man with wrap on wrist sits across from woman in suit


Paulson & Nace, PLLC: A Pioneer in Personal Injury Law

by Best Lawyers

Since its inception more than 40 years ago, Paulson & Nace, PLLC, a Washington D.C., Maryland and West Virginia-based personal injury firm, has always led with compassion first. Here are some key insights from the firm on how to go about filing a personal injury claim.

Group of lawyers meet around a conference table