Insight

PA Supreme Court Strikes Down Constitutional Amendment

Best Lawyers weighs in on the recent Pennsylvania Supreme Court decision to strike down on "Marsy's Law" and what that could mean for victim's rights around the state.

PA Supreme Court Decision on Marsy's Law
GS

Gregory Sirico

April 28, 2022 09:00 AM

On December 21, 2021, in a 6-1 ruling, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court struck down “Marsy’s Law,” a victims’ rights amendment initially enacted in 2009, which was expected to have added a significant number of new provisions to Article I of the state’s constitution in the following months. Marsy’s Law, which was named after Marsalee Nicholas, a California college student who was murdered by her ex-boyfriend in 1983, was at the top of Pennsylvania’s legislative list going into 2021.

The amendment clarifies the definition of the term “victim” by including those directly affected by the crime as well as any “spouse, parent, grandparent, child, sibling, grandchild or guardian, and any person with a relationship to the victim that is substantially similar to a listed relationship.” Marsy’s Law has already been proposed and adopted by 12 separate U.S. states, with Henry Nicholas, co-founder of Broadcom Corporation and brother of Marsy, acting as the campaign’s primary backer. Established in 2009 by Nicholas himself, Marsy’s Law for All LLC is a national organization dedicated to the advocation of Marsy’s Law, allocating roughly $6.85 million a year to their awareness efforts alone.

In the 2019 Pennsylvania state elections, an overwhelming majority of state residents voted in favor of upholding the amendment, with an approximate count tallied at 1.8 million in favor to 600,000 against. Despite this majority vote, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court and Commonwealth Court began to carry out a dismissal of the amendment entirely. Two months prior to the election, the prominent civil rights group, League of Women Voters, already began to administer petitions against the Commonwealth Court on a statewide level to permanently uphold and instate Marsy’s Law as a fixture to the constitution. Eventually, the petition led them to file a series of lawsuits against the state, claiming the dismissal of the amendment could be considered unconstitutional.

In a stark contrast, the Pennsylvania chapter of the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU), long time opponents of Marsy’s Law, argued the amendment was entirely unconstitutional, claiming it prompts too many changes to the state’s constitution. Similarly, Pennsylvania Supreme Court Justice Debra Todd described the 2019 ballot put forth to the voters of Pennsylvania as “a collection of amendments which added a multiplicity of new rights to our Constitution. The new rights were not interrelated in purpose and function, the manner in which it was presented to the voters denied them their right to consider and vote on each change separately.”

If upheld, this legislative and ballot measure would have given Pennsylvania crime victims 15 newly specified constitutional rights, including a right to carry on proceedings free of any unreasonable delays; a right to provide information that can be considered by the council of the offender; and lastly a right to refuse any interviews, depositions or other discovery requests. Going forward, Pennsylvania lawyers and lawmakers from around the state expect a wide array of spinoff claims to be filed in 2022 as victims of major criminal offenses continue to fight to make their voices heard.

Related Articles

An Army of Nancy


by Rachel Shrewsbury

The horrific stories out of Guantánamo Bay nearly caused me to lose faith in the American principles of liberty and justice. Nancy Hollander turned out to be the ray of hope I was looking for.

Q&A with Nancy Hollander

Courtroom Mastery


by Justin Smulison

Victor H. Pribanic recalled the excitement of returning to the courtroom in late 2021 for a medical negligence case that could help set a new course for Pribanic & Pribanic’s trial advocacy.

Victor H. Pribanic Makes Return to Courtroom

Pennsylvania "Lawyer of the Year" 2022


by Best Lawyers

Wendelynne J. Newton is honored as 2022 "Lawyer of the Year" in Pennsylvania for Litigation-Healthcare.

Pennsylvania "Lawyer of the Year" 2022

Pennsylvania’s Best Lawyers 2022


by Best Lawyers

Our Pennsylvania’s Best Lawyers 2022 digital publication features top-ranked legal talent in Pennsylvania.

Pennsylvania’s Best Lawyers 2022

Success and Leadership by All Measures


by Justin Smulison

Lubin & Meyer Continues to Secure Medical Malpractice and Injury Results That Protect Victims and Inspire Change

Lubin & Meyer Continue to Secure Legal Result

Jumping Hurdles toward the Finish Line


by Meredith Aldridge, Colleen Welch, and Alicia Hall

Forty-five years of progress with Title IX.

Title IX seeks to change cultural norms

Trending Articles

Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch in America for 2023


by Best Lawyers

The third edition of Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch in America™ highlights the legal talent of lawyers who have been in practice less than 10 years.

Three arrows made of lines and dots on blue background

The Best Lawyers in New Zealand™ 2024 Awards


by Best Lawyers

The Best Lawyers in New Zealand 2024 awards include an elite field of top lawyers and law firms.

Auckland, New Zealand Skyline at twilight

Presenting The Best Lawyers in Singapore™ 2024


by Best Lawyers

Best Lawyers offers the most prestigious awards for lawyers and law firms in Singapore for 2024.

Singapore skyline at night

Announcing the 2023 The Best Lawyers in America Honorees


by Best Lawyers

Only the top 5.3% of all practicing lawyers in the U.S. were selected by their peers for inclusion in the 29th edition of The Best Lawyers in America®.

Gold strings and dots connecting to form US map

The Best Lawyers in Australia™ 2024 Launch


by Best Lawyers

Best Lawyers is excited to announce The Best Lawyers in Australia™ for 2023, including the top lawyers and law firms from Australia.

Australian Parliament beside water at sunset

Announcing The Best Lawyers in Japan™ 2024


by Best Lawyers

We are proud to present the 2024 edition of Best Lawyers awards for Japan which include the top lawyers and law firms in the country.

Mt. Fuji in the background with fall leaves and structure in front

IN PARTNERSHIP

Paulson & Nace, PLLC: A Pioneer in Personal Injury Law


by Best Lawyers

Since its inception more than 40 years ago, Paulson & Nace, PLLC, a Washington D.C., Maryland and West Virginia-based personal injury firm, has always led with compassion first. Here are some key insights from the firm on how to go about filing a personal injury claim.

Group of lawyers meet around a conference table

The Best Lawyers in South Africa™ 2023


by Best Lawyers

Best Lawyers proudly announces lawyers recognized in South Africa for 2023.

South African flag

IN PARTNERSHIP

Salvi & Maher, LLP: Illinois and Wisconsin's Personal Injury Firm


by Justin Smulison

For more than 35 years, Salvi & Maher LLP has defended their clients throughout Illinois and Wisconsin in various areas of personal injury law, including medical malpractice, motor vehicle accidents, premises liability and trucking litigation.

Skyline of Chicago with green river and blue background

IN PARTNERSHIP

Athea Trial Lawyers


by Justin Smulison

Athea Trial Lawyers is a nationally recognized firm who has received record-breaking victories throughout the country on behalf of personal injury victims.

women with shades of blue in mass arrangement

Announcing The Best Lawyers in Germany™ 2023


by Best Lawyers

The results include an elite field of top lawyers and firms from Germany.

Black, red and yellow stripes

Choosing a Title Company: What a Seller Should Expect


by Roy D. Oppenheim

When it comes to choosing a title company, how much power exactly does a seller have?

Choosing the Title Company As Seller

Famous Songs Unprotected by Copyright Could Mean Royalties for Some


by Michael B. Fein

A guide to navigating copyright claims on famous songs.

Can I Sing "Happy Birthday" in Public?

What the Courts Say About Recording in the Classroom


by Christina Henagen Peer and Peter Zawadski

Students and parents are increasingly asking to use audio devices to record what's being said in the classroom. But is it legal? A recent ruling offer gives the answer to a question confusing parents and administrators alike.

Is It Legal for Students to Record Teachers?

Could Reign Supreme End with the Queen?


by Sara Collin

Canada is revisiting the notion of abolishing the monarchy after Queen Elizabeth II’s passing, but many Canadians and lawmakers are questioning if Canada could, should and would follow through.

Teacup on saucer over image of Queen's eye

IN PARTNERSHIP

Mastering the Art of Trial Practice


by John Fields

With its billion-dollar track record, Morelli Law Firm has earned a reputation as one of the country's most successful trial firms.

Morelli and team at table in office with windows