Insight

Rental House of Cards

The pandemic devastated uncountable businesses worldwide. A recent court case involving some of Canada’s most venerable companies and pension funds sheds light on the stringency of the country’s commercial leases—and the judiciary’s reluctance to meddle in sophisticated commercial contracts amid a “black swan” event.

Toppling house of cards
TD

Tyler D’Angelo

September 29, 2022 04:30 PM

A handful of principles are foundational to valuing commercial real estate. The best-known, of course, is “location, location, location.” For many properties, however, “foot traffic = revenue” is equally important.

Restaurants, retail spaces, offices and hotels all generally thrive on the continual congregation of people in desirable spaces. If tables or rooms do not turn over, or revolving doors cease revolving, revenue generation becomes much more difficult.

These concepts are not academic. They’re critical, for example, in determining rent. In many real estate subclasses, a site’s location and foot traffic will inform the revenue a tenant expects to generate, which in turn informs the rent it can pay—which in turn informs (or perhaps confirms) the rent a landlord expects to receive. That rent ultimately plays a key role in determining what a lender will lend and what a buyer will pay: in other words, the site’s value. A common commercial real estate structure sports a robust foundation of tenants fueled by foot traffic, with floors of freehold and mortgage capital built atop triple net leases.

But black swans ignore economic principles. When the COVID-19 pandemic landed in Canada in March 2020, governments reacted as elsewhere: Venues that encouraged social gatherings were largely shuttered, and those that remained open faced strict capacity limits. From a commercial real estate perspective, people staying at home en masse neuters both location and foot traffic, and fundamentally limits the ability of many tenants to generate enough revenue to pay rent—as well as the ability of landlords to service their mortgages. The structure faced a serious threat of becoming a house of cards (and perhaps would have but for unprecedented wage and rent support from governments).

The trial court found HBC had been a tenant at Hillcrest Mall since 1978, had paid its rent on time for 42 straight years and suffered an average decline in sales at Hillcrest Mall of 69% compared to before the pandemic."

It was not long before lawsuits around the world sought to answer a fundamental leasing question: In a triple net lease, with the tenant responsible for paying base rent and its share of the landlord’s operating costs without regard to any claim, setoff or deduction, who bears the risk of a black swan that shuts doors and prohibits foot traffic?

In Canada, Hudson’s Bay Company (HBC), the oldest corporation in the country and a major retailer, withheld rent under a number of its leases beginning in April 2020. In the case at hand (pertaining to Hillcrest Mall outside Toronto, where HBC is the anchor tenant), HBC ultimately brought its landlord, an affiliate of Oxford Properties Group (itself a pension fund landlord), to court in October 2020, alleging Oxford had defaulted under the lease. One day later, Oxford formally commenced proceedings to terminate the lease, forcing HBC to also seek “relief from forfeiture”—a judicial “shield,” not unlike bankruptcy laws, granting a tenant breathing room to cure a default and permitting continued possession of a premises pending a cure.

The main issue before the court was interpretation of Section 20 of Ontario’s Commercial Tenancies Act (CTA) codifying a tenant’s right to obtain relief from forfeiture:

Where a lessor is proceeding by action or otherwise to enforce a right of reentry or forfeiture . . . the lessee may . . . apply to the court for relief, and the court may grant such relief as, having regard to the proceeding and conduct of the parties under Section 19 and to all the other circumstances, the court thinks fit, and on such terms as to payment of rent, costs, expenses, damages, compensation, penalty or otherwise, including the granting of an injunction to restrain any like breach in the future as the court considers just. (Emphasis added.)

At trial, citing the broad language in Section 20 of the CTA, HBC argued the court not only had jurisdiction to stay an eviction notice, but in light of an unprecedented event, also had jurisdiction to grant rent abatement/forgiveness. HBC had, up to that point, been a model tenant: The trial court found HBC had been a tenant at Hillcrest Mall since 1978, had paid its rent on time for 42 straight years and suffered an average decline in sales at Hillcrest Mall of 69% compared to before the pandemic.

The trial court granted HBC relief from forfeiture. Critically, it also ordered rent deferrals (rather than forgiveness). The court imposed a phased rent repayment schedule whereby HBC was to pay partial rent until November 2021 and pay all arrears in March 2022 at an interest rate of prime plus 2%. None of this was provided for in HBC’s lease—and, in fact, the lease stipulated interest on arrears at prime plus 4%.

Both parties appealed to the Ontario Court of Appeal. HBC argued the trial court did not go far enough, and once again sought rent forgiveness, arguing Section 20 allows courts to “override the terms of a lease if justice so requires”—particularly when a “model tenant” is suffering the blunt effects of a pandemic. Oxford, for its part, argued the trial court went too far—that despite equitable language like “fit” and “just,” Section 20 does not include a right to grant rent deferrals (let alone rent forgiveness), nor any right to “rewrite the commercial bargain made by the parties to take into account unforeseen events.”

In a unanimous decision released this August 15, the Court of Appeal found in favor of Oxford. Relief from forfeiture, the court said, is a “specific and narrow” remedy that allows the tenant breathing room to put the lease in good standing. It “does not contemplate a recalibration of existing rights and obligations under the lease . . . to reflect what the court sees as a fair arrangement in light of unforeseen developments.” The court continued:

To order that a tenant is not required to pay the agreed-upon rent is not to grant relief from forfeiture of the lease but is to grant relief from compliance with the terms of the lease. Nor does . . . abatement or reduction of rent . . . preserve the lease. Instead, it alters a basic and fundamental term of the lease . . . I accept that the impact of COVID-19 and the restrictions on retail businesses that followed can be taken into account when setting the terms of relief for forfeiture . . . [It] may dictate a term allowing the tenant some additional time to bring itself into compliance with the lease. I do not, however, accept that the economic impact of COVID-19 can be taken as a basis for fundamentally altering the remedy from one of relief from forfeiture to one imposing new terms in the lease.

Although all back rent and arrears had already been paid by the time the appeal was argued, the Court of Appeal also rejected the trial court’s repayment schedule and recalibration of the interest rate on arrears, finding that any grace period to repay rent should have been limited to a reasonable amount of time for HBC to bring the lease into good standing.

This article is a limited review of an important decision, and it does not address lower-court rulings and orders at length. Nevertheless, the HBC case is a reminder from the Court of Appeal that a bargain struck is a bargain struck, and courts should resist using judicial discretion to alter contracts properly consummated between highly sophisticated entities. A precedent of imposing judicial rent deferrals under the auspices of relief from forfeiture could have caused considerable commercial uncertainty in the real estate world and upended a fundamental principle of commercial leasing: Triple net leases are typically carefree to the landlord except as otherwise set forth in the lease. Leasing law is often a labyrinth, but in this regard at least, and insofar as Ontario is concerned, black swans do not shift the allocation of risk to the tenant.

Tyler D’Angelo is a partner and co-head of the Real Estate Group at Goodmans LLP. His practice focuses on a wide range of real estate matters, including purchases, sales, financings, joint ventures, leases, construction and development agreements, and real estate aspects of larger commercial agreements.

Headline Image: ISTOCK/terrainscan, ISTOCK/BOOGICH

Related Articles

Hobbling the War Machine


by Shawn C.D. Neylan

Since late spring, the Canadian government has been actively sanctioning business and political entities, as well as numerous individuals, with alleged ties to Vladimir Putin and the Russian military, including some in Belarus. You can’t tell the players without a scorecard—so here’s an overview.

Military tank with prohibited symbol

Growing Canadian Business Abroad


by Didier Culat

Canadian entrepreneurs looking to expand their businesses beyond the geographic confines of their home dominion must consider a vast range of questions to ensure they’re fit to branch out. Here’s a quick primer.

Green arrows rising with Canada in backdrop

The Antipodean Advantage


by Gordon Grieve and Tony Britten-Jones

As the pandemic recedes, Australia remains one of the best countries in which to invest. The commercial law experts at Piper Alderman review the country’s advantages when it comes to outside money looking for outsized returns.

Man pointing to cave wall

It’s Official: Options for Challenging “Official Marks” in Canada


by Jamie-Lynn Kraft and Philip Lapin

“Official marks” are a strangely obscure corner of Canadian intellectual-property law. What are they, what explains their strength and what can a business owner in search of a trademark do to challenge them?

Two griffins on royal crest

Latinflation


by Alejandra Daroch, Domingo Russi and Jaime Carey Astaburuaga

Long a beacon of economic stability in South America, Chile has been buffeted lately by the global rise in inflation. Can a key element of its monetary policy help it weather the storm?

Waves crashing into lighthouse

The Future of Trade is Digital


by Alan de Rochefort-Reynolds, Daniel Allman and Jo Feldman

Digital information increasingly drives bilateral and multilateral trade throughout the Indo-Pacific region. It behooves countries to devise agreements governing the use and exchange of the enormous amounts of vital data generated every day.

Neon colored boxes in circle with black background

Competitive Balance


by David Feldman and Peter Flynn

Major amendments to Canada’s Competition Act were rushed through Parliament this June with scarcely any debate. They will likely have enormous antitrust ramifications—and businesses had better be ready.

Blaring megaphone sounds the alarm

The Carbon Conundrum


by Martin Hamer and Natalie Kopplow

Companies that trade internationally might soon face a “carbon tariff” when importing certain goods into the European Union. Why is the EU doing this—and how will it affect world trade?

Power plant billowing smoke

An Employer’s Guidebook to Responding to Online Harassment


by Belle Harris and Brent Siler

Navigating online defamation against your business requires strategic responses. Two employment lawyers guide how to leverage contracts, understand social media limitations and the risks of legal action.

Image of person pushing giant phone with mouth and words coming out

IN PARTNERSHIP

The Wagner Law Group: ERISA and Employment Law


by The Wagner Law Group

For more than 25 years, The Wagner Law Group has combined the personalized attention and reasonable rates of small law firms with the specialization and sophistication of large firms to tackle all of their clients' ERISA and Employment Law needs.

Female Attorney in a Gray Suit Presenting to a Female Judge

IN PARTNERSHIP

The Long, Short, Thick and Thin of It


by Avrohom Gefen

“Appearance discrimination” based on employees’ height and weight is the latest hot-button issue in employment law. Here’s a guide to avoid discrimination.

Woman stands in front of mirror holding suit jacket

IN PARTNERSHIP

Businesses Must Prepare for the New Department of Labor Independent Contractor Rule


by Kirby Black and Steven T. Clark

Two employment law lawyers explain how a new DOL rule making it more likely workers will be classified as employees, rather than independent contractors, has caused legal challenges and prompted businesses to reassess worker status and policies.

Block with outline of person slightly out of place from other blocks

IN PARTNERSHIP

Gust Rosenfeld P.L.C. on Protecting Arizona Employers


by Justin Smulison

Gust Rosenfeld attorney Robert D. Haws discusses emerging trends in employment litigation and how the firm’s Employment and Education Law practice groups have protected clients in and out of Arizona’s courtrooms.

Gust Rosenfeld P.L.C. on Protecting Arizona Employers

IN PARTNERSHIP

5 Things To Do if You’re at Fault in a Car Accident


by Alex De Castroverde

Have you been in a car accident in Las Vegas, NV? Learn more about what to do if you were at fault. Contact a car accident attorney to discuss your case.

Man in blue jacket standing in front of smoking car

IN PARTNERSHIP

What if I’m Partially at Fault for My Car Accident?


by Christopher M. Davis

Experienced personal injury lawyer Christopher M. Davis explains what to do when you are partially at fault in a car accident in the state of Washington.

Man and woman discussing black car crashed into white car

6 Ways a Lawyer Can Help You With Your Medical Malpractice Claim


by Adam Malone

If you believe you have a medical malpractice claim, contact an experienced medical malpractice lawyer. Read on to learn how they can help with your claim.

Doctor in white lab coat showing x-ray to patient in blue scrubs

Trending Articles

Announcing the 2023 The Best Lawyers in America Honorees


by Best Lawyers

Only the top 5.3% of all practicing lawyers in the U.S. were selected by their peers for inclusion in the 29th edition of The Best Lawyers in America®.

Gold strings and dots connecting to form US map

Announcing the 2022 Best Lawyers® in the United States


by Best Lawyers

The results include an elite field of top lawyers listed in the 28th Edition of The Best Lawyers in America® and in the 2nd Edition of Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch in America for 2022.

2022 Best Lawyers Listings for United States

2021 Best Lawyers: The Global Issue


by Best Lawyers

The 2021 Global Issue features top legal talent from the most recent editions of Best Lawyers and Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch worldwide.

2021 Best Lawyers: The Global Issue

The U.S. Best Lawyers Voting Season Is Open


by Best Lawyers

The voting season for the 31st edition of The Best Lawyers in America® and the 5th edition of Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch® in America is officially underway, and we are offering some helpful advice to this year’s voters.

Golden figures of people standing on blue surface connected by white lines

How To Find A Pro Bono Lawyer


by Best Lawyers

Best Lawyers dives into the vital role pro bono lawyers play in ensuring access to justice for all and the transformative impact they have on communities.

Hands joined around a table with phone, paper, pen and glasses

The Best Lawyers in Australia™ 2024 Launch


by Best Lawyers

Best Lawyers is excited to announce The Best Lawyers in Australia™ for 2023, including the top lawyers and law firms from Australia.

Australian Parliament beside water at sunset

How Palworld Is Testing the Limits of Nintendo’s Legal Power


by Gregory Sirico

Many are calling the new game Palworld “Pokémon GO with guns,” noting the games striking similarities. Experts speculate how Nintendo could take legal action.

Animated figures with guns stand on top of creatures

What the Courts Say About Recording in the Classroom


by Christina Henagen Peer and Peter Zawadski

Students and parents are increasingly asking to use audio devices to record what's being said in the classroom. But is it legal? A recent ruling offer gives the answer to a question confusing parents and administrators alike.

Is It Legal for Students to Record Teachers?

Inflation Escalation


by Ashley S. Wagner

Inflation and rising costs are at the forefront of everyone’s mind as we enter 2023. The current volatile market makes it more important than ever to understand the rent escalation clauses in current and future commercial lease agreements.

Suited figure in front of rising market and inflated balloon

The Upcycle Conundrum


by Karen Kreider Gaunt

Laudable or litigious? What you need to know about potential copyright and trademark infringement when repurposing products.

Repurposed Products and Copyright Infringemen

8 Different Types of Criminal Defenses in Law


by Best Lawyers

Learn about the different types of criminal defenses available in law, including innocence, self-defense, insanity and more. Protect your rights today.

Silver handcuffs laying on finger printed papers

A Celebration of Excellence: The Best Lawyers in Canada 2024 Awards


by Best Lawyers

As we embark on the 18th edition of The Best Lawyers in Canada™, we are excited to highlight excellence and top legal talent across the country.

Abstract image of red and white Canada flag in triangles

Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch in America for 2023


by Best Lawyers

The third edition of Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch in America™ highlights the legal talent of lawyers who have been in practice less than 10 years.

Three arrows made of lines and dots on blue background

Wage and Overtime Laws for Truck Drivers


by Greg Mansell

For truck drivers nationwide, underpayment and overtime violations are just the beginning of a long list of problems. Below we explore the wages you are entitled to but may not be receiving.

Truck Driver Wage and Overtime Laws in the US

Choosing a Title Company: What a Seller Should Expect


by Roy D. Oppenheim

When it comes to choosing a title company, how much power exactly does a seller have?

Choosing the Title Company As Seller

The 2024 Best Lawyers in Spain™


by Best Lawyers

Best Lawyers is honored to announce the 16th edition of The Best Lawyers in Spain™ and the third edition of Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch in Spain™ for 2024.

Tall buildings and rushing traffic against clouds and sun in sky