Insight

Arizona Case Update - Rule 42 Change of Judge

Arizona Case Update - Rule 42 Change of Judge

Dev K. Sethi

Dev K. Sethi

October 14, 2019 07:45 PM

Coffee v. Superior Court, No. 1 CA-SA 18-0251 (App. Div. I, June 20, 2019) (J. Weinzweig) https://www.azcourts.gov/Portals/0/OpinionFiles/Div1/2019/1%20CA-SA%2018-0251.pdf Successful party on appeal or special action may notice the trial judge where that judge is ordered to reconsider a prior ruling based upon new evidence.

In this special action, petitioner father challenged the trial court's order that his minor son immediately move from Arizona to Kansas to live with his mother. The Arizona Court of Appeals upon special action found that the petitioner had been denied due process and ordered the superior court to hold a second evidentiary hearing where petitioner is afforded due process, consider the mother's request for modified child support and the father's counter-petition to modify legal decision-making. Petitioner then noticed the trial judge pursuant to Rule 42.1(e) of the Arizona Rules of Civil Procedure. The trial court denied the request for a new judge so petitioner again sought special action relief. The Arizona Court of Appeals accepted jurisdiction and granted petitioner relief.

First the court of appeals noted that jurisdiction never transfers from the superior court to the court of appeals even when the court of appeals accepts jurisdiction of a special action. A special action represents a separate, original proceeding where an appellate court examines the action or inaction of public officials and may issue orders affecting future proceedings in a case. Unless the court of appeals issues a stay the trial court may otherwise proceed in the underlying action during special action proceedings.

Rule 42.1(e) authorizes a party to obtain a new trial judge “[i]n actions remanded from an appellate court [if] the appellate decision requires a new trial and the movant has not previously removed a trial judge in the action. . . . Rule 42.1(e) hinges on principles of fairness and impartiality. It is concerned about trial judges who might prejudge an issue on remand, having already tackled the issue, heard the arguments and reached a conclusion. . . It also guards against the ‘possibility of judicial bias where trial judges might begrudge the parties who successfully seek review of their rulings.”

Because here the court of appeals decision required the trial court to reconsider issues already decided based upon evidence not previously considered, petitioner has a right to exercise his first notice of change of judge under rule 42. Significantly, the court of appeals interpreted the word “trial” broadly enough to include a contested evidentiary hearing finding no “magic” in the specific terms “trial” or “reversal.” Critical to the court of appeals decision was the fact that the trial court was being asked to reconsider a ruling it had already made based upon new evidence and was not being asked to simply explain a ruling it had already made. Similarly an order that the trial court perform ministerial function would not open the door for a change of judge. Finally, there need be no showing that the trial judge is biased or “upset” with a movant who successfully challenges their decision on appeal or by special action in support of a rule 42.1(e) motion.

Trending Articles

2025 Best Lawyers Awards Announced: Honoring Outstanding Legal Professionals Across the U.S.


by Jennifer Verta

Introducing the 31st edition of The Best Lawyers in America and the fifth edition of Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch in America.

Digital map of the United States illuminated by numerous bright lights

Unveiling the 2025 Best Lawyers Awards Canada: Celebrating Legal Excellence


by Jennifer Verta

Presenting the 19th edition of The Best Lawyers in Canada and the 4th edition of Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch in Canada.

Digital map of Canadathis on illuminated by numerous bright lights

Discover The Best Lawyers in Spain 2025 Edition


by Jennifer Verta

Highlighting Spain’s leading legal professionals and rising talents.

Flags of Spain, representing Best Lawyers country

Legal Distinction on Display: 15th Edition of The Best Lawyers in France™


by Best Lawyers

The industry’s best lawyers and firms working in France are revealed in the newly released, comprehensive the 15th Edition of The Best Lawyers in France™.

French flag in front of country's outline

Unveiling the 2025 Best Lawyers Editions in Brazil, Mexico, Portugal and South Africa


by Jennifer Verta

Best Lawyers celebrates the finest in law, reaffirming its commitment to the global legal community.

Flags of Brazil, Mexico, Portugal and South Africa, representing Best Lawyers countries

Presenting the 2025 Best Lawyers Editions in Chile, Colombia, Peru and Puerto Rico


by Jennifer Verta

Celebrating top legal professionals in South America and the Caribbean.

Flags of Puerto Rico, Chile, Colombia, and Peru, representing countries featured in the Best Lawyers

Announcing the 13th Edition of Best Lawyers Rankings in the United Kingdom


by Best Lawyers

Best Lawyers is proud to announce the newest edition of legal rankings in the United Kingdom, marking the 13th consecutive edition of awards in the country.

British flag in front of country's outline

Prop 36 California 2024: California’s Path to Stricter Sentencing and Criminal Justice Reform


by Jennifer Verta

Explore how Prop 36 could shape California's sentencing laws and justice reform.

Illustrated Hands Breaking Chains Against a Bright Red Background

Celebrating Excellence in Law: 11th Edition of Best Lawyers in Italy™


by Best Lawyers

Best Lawyers announces the 11th edition of The Best Lawyers in Italy™, which features an elite list of awards showcasing Italy's current legal talent.

Italian flag in front of country's outline

Tampa Appeals Court ‘Sends Clear Message,” Ensuring School Tax Referendum Stays on Ballot


by Gregory Sirico

Hillsborough County's tax referendum is back on the 2024 ballot, promising $177 million for schools and empowering residents to decide the future of education.

Graduation cap in air surrounded by pencils and money

Find the Best Lawyers for Your Needs


by Jennifer Verta

Discover how Best Lawyers simplifies the attorney search process.

A focused woman with dark hair wearing a green top and beige blazer, working on a tablet in a dimly

Key Developments and Trends in U.S. Commercial Litigation


by Justin Smulison

Whether it's multibillion-dollar water cleanliness verdicts or college athletes vying for the right to compensation, the state of litigation remains strong.

Basketball sits in front of stacks of money

The Human Cost


by Justin Smulison

2 new EU laws aim to reshape global business by enforcing ethical supply chains, focusing on human rights and sustainability

Worker wearing hat stands in field carrying equipemtn

Paramount Hit With NY Class Action Lawsuit Over Mass Layoffs


by Gregory Sirico

Paramount Global faces a class action lawsuit for allegedly violating New York's WARN Act after laying off 300+ employees without proper notice in September.

Animated man in suit being erased with Paramount logo in background

Introduction to Demand Generation for Law Firms


by Jennifer Verta

Learn the essentials of demand gen for law firms and how these strategies can drive client acquisition, retention, and long-term success.

Illustration of a hand holding a magnet, attracting icons representing individuals towards a central

Social Media for Law Firms: The Essential Beginner’s Guide to Digital Success


by Jennifer Verta

Maximize your law firm’s online impact with social media.

3D pixelated thumbs-up icon in red and orange on a blue and purple background.