Timothy S. Schafer

Timothy S. Schafer is the founding partner of Schafer & Schafer and a seasoned trial lawyer with more than four decades of experience fighting for the injured. Over the course of his career, he’s recovered more than $500 million in verdicts and settlements, including over 100 individual cases where he secured $1 million or more. Timothy has been consistently recognized as one of the top trial lawyers in Indiana and the country, earning honors like Best Lawyer of the Year by U.S. News and the prestigious Litigator Award, given to the top 1% of lawyers nationwide, as well as a nomination for National Trial Lawyer of the Year.

Timothy’s reputation is built on experience, results, and a deep commitment to the people he represents. He’s proud to work alongside his sons at the family firm, combining legal skill with strong family values. Whether he’s preparing for trial or working through negotiations, Timothy brings focus, care, and a drive to help people rebuild after serious injuries. His work has been featured in major outlets like USA Today, The New York Times, The Wall Street Journal, and several Chicago news networks.