Works at
Easley Appellate Practice PLLC

1 Best Lawyers award

Easley Appellate Practice PLLC logo

Biography

Dorothy of Easley Appellate Practice PLLC focuses her work on Appellate Practice nationally, from her office in Miami, Florida. She is the published author of Successful Federal Appeals in All Circuit Courts: A Practical Guide for Busy Lawyers, a practical resource addressing federal appellate procedure and appeal strategies. She has advanced hundreds of appeals. Her work reflects a long-standing interest in legal writing, careful analysis of the record, and clear presentation of complex legal issues to appellate courts.

Dorothy’s background reflects a strong work ethic developed early in life. She grew up on a farm, learned to drive a tractor, and worked on a forestry logging crew for room and board while attending college in the mountains of North Carolina. She earned a Master of Science, summa cum laude, in forest genetics from the State University of New York College of Environmental Science and Forestry (SUNY/ESF), where she also served as a Research Fellow. She later received her Juris Doctor, cum laude, from the University of Miami School of Law. While in law school, she served as Executive Editor of the Inter-American Law Review and worked as a Research Assistant on scholarship addressing constitutional and Latin American law. She also interned with the Third District Court of Appeal of the State of Florida.

Before founding Easley Appellate Practice PLLC in Miami, Dorothy practiced appellate law in large law firm settings and helped build and manage appellate departments. Her professional experience also includes work as a published research scientist in Latin America and service as a university law professor. These roles have contributed to her approach to appellate advocacy, which emphasizes detailed research, precise writing, and thoughtful analysis of the legal issues presented on appeal.

Dorothy is board certified in Appellate Practice by The Florida Bar. Board certification in Appellate Practice is The Florida Bar's highest credential for attorneys specializing in civil, administrative, or criminal appeals. It recognizes attorneys who have demonstrated exceptional competence, highest ethical standards, and extensive experience in state or federal appellate courts. Less than two-tenths of one percent (< 0.2%) of all Florida lawyers are Board Certified in Appellate Practice. here are fewer than 200 attorneys who hold this highly exclusive certification

Dorothy previously served as the elected Chair of the Florida Bar’s Appellate Practice Section, an organization of more than 1,700 members, and as Vice Chair of the Appellate Court Rules Committee. Through Easley Appellate Practice PLLC, she works closely with a team of appellate attorneys and appellate paralegals on appeals in state and federal courts, including federal appeals throughout the United States.

Her work in Appellate Practice includes briefing, oral argument preparation, and strategic guidance for trial counsel handling matters that may proceed to appeal. Dorothy’s writing and advocacy focus on presenting the record and the law in a clear and persuasive manner for appellate judges reviewing complex cases.

Works at
Easley Appellate Practice PLLC

1 Best Lawyers award

Easley Appellate Practice PLLC logo

Locations

Languages

  • English
  • Spanish

Education

  • University of Miami School of Law, Law, graduated 1994
  • State University of New York College of Environmental Science and Forestry, M.S. Forest Genetics
  • Warren Wilson College, B.A. Forest Management/Minor Economics

Bar Admissions

  • Florida, Florida Bar

Court Admissions

  • US Supreme Court
  • US Court of Appeals for the First Circuit
  • US Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit
  • US Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit
  • US Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit
  • US Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit
  • US Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit
  • US Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit
  • US Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit
  • US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit
  • US Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit
  • US Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit

Affiliations

  • Appellate Court Rules Committee - Former Vice Chair
  • Florida Bar Appellate Certification Committee - Committee Member, Former
  • Florida Bar Appellate Practice Section - Former Chair
  • Rosemary Barkett Appellate American Inn of Court - Past President
  • Third District Court of Appeal Historical Society - Past President

Client Testimonials

Awards & Focus

Recognized in The Best Lawyers in America® 2026 for work in:
  • Appellate Practice
Additional Areas of Practice:
  • Litigation - Intellectual Property
  • Health Care Law
  • Medical Malpractice Law - Defendants
  • Copyright Law
  • Closely Held Companies and Family Businesses Law
  • Commercial Litigation
  • Litigation - Health Care
  • Family Law
Awards:
  • Florida Bar Board Certified in Appellate Law, Certified and consistently Recertified since 2003

    Florida Bar 2009 Award for Excellence in the Promotion of Board Certification

    AV® Preeminent™ Peer Review Rating from Martindale-Hubbell®

    Florida Super Lawyer (top 5 percent of Florida lawyers), Super Lawyer Magazine, annually since 2006

    Ranked Top 100 Lawyers, South Florida, in Super Lawyer Magazine 2010

    Ranked Top 50 Women Lawyers in Super Lawyer Magazine 2009, 2010

    Legal Elite (top 1.9 percent of all Florida Lawyers), Trend Magazine

    Top Appellate Lawyer, South Florida Legal Guide

    National Association of Distinguished Counsel, Top One Percent, since 2016

    Best Attorneys of America, Rue Ratings, since 2015

    Best Law Firms of America, Rue Ratings, since 2015

    ALM Recognition of Easley in Top Women Leaders in the Law, featured in Fortune Magazine, 2014 and again in 2015

    ALM Recognition of EAP Among South Florida's Top Lawyers, Legal Leaders in Appellate, Business/Commercial Law

Additional Information

Spinning circle Big letter B

Q&A

Easley Appellate Practice focuses on appellate litigation. The firm has handled hundreds of appeals in Florida and federal appellate courts across the United States and the US Supreme Court. The firm’s attorneys have been licensed since 1994 and hold Board Certification in Appellate Practice from The Florida Bar and only those certified as such can use the title of "appeal experts" or "appeal specialists".

Our work centers on federal and Florida appeals involving business law, contract disputes, intellectual property, business torts, health law, and family law. We assist clients and trial counsel with expert appellate briefing, oral argument, and other issues that arise during the appellate process.

We practice before the U.S. Supreme Court, all United States Courts of Appeals, the Florida Supreme Court, and Florida’s District Courts of Appeal, handling more than 500 appeals to date. In addition to appellate matters, Easley Appellate Practice provides strategic litigation support in trial courts and has assisted in more than 50 trials.

1. How do I know that I have an appeal?

Litigants often are emotionally drained after a trial or lengthy litigation and want to appeal a losing decision or an unsatisfactory judgment or sentence. But before spending more time or money, an important question needs to be answered first: whether there is a potential appealable or defendable issue. Trial lawyers have to handle many different tasks and often must do them quickly. Appeals, however, involve a different type of review and analysis focused on what occurred in the trial court and how the law was applied. Before raising any issue on appeal, the record must show that (1) the issue was properly presented to the trial court and (2) the trial court refused the requested relief. If trial counsel did not involve an appellate lawyer during the trial stage, it is possible that certain issues were not raised or were not properly objected to, which may affect whether those issues can later be considered by the court of appeals. To determine whether issues were correctly preserved for appellate review—and whether there may be an issue worth appealing or defending—it can be helpful to consult with an appellate lawyer who can review the record and discuss general appeal questions with you. If you would like a case analysis, we offer a review of your case for a minimal fee. If our review and research indicate that we may be able to assist with prosecuting or defending your appeal, that fee will be credited toward your appeal retainer. If the issues you wish to raise or defend were not preserved for appellate review, we can provide an honest assessment, suggest obtaining a second opinion, and potentially help you avoid spending significant resources on an appeal that may not present reviewable issues.

Appellate attorneys are expected to have a deep command of the law and often serve as the “trial lawyer’s lawyer.” That role requires continual study and ongoing education across a wide range of legal subjects.

Maintaining independence in appellate counsel is also important when advancing or defending an appeal. Bringing in counsel focused on appeals often makes the process more efficient and cost-conscious than relying solely on trial counsel. For that reason, Easley Appellate is frequently contacted first by trial lawyers and then by the clients themselves when decisions are being made about whether to involve separate appellate counsel or have us handle the appeal. Early involvement often helps identify key legal issues and manage risk throughout the process.

Like medicine, modern litigation has developed distinct roles. A general practitioner may not perform heart surgery, and in much the same way, the appellate process involves a specialized set of skills that differ significantly from those used at the trial level. Trial lawyers focus heavily on discovery, witness presentation, and jury advocacy, while appellate work centers on analyzing legal error, applying standards of review, and presenting issues to appellate judges.

Senior U.S. Circuit Judge Ruggero Aldisert of the Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit observed that appellate advocacy demands a different kind of preparation and discipline than trial work. Trial practice often emphasizes facts and witness testimony, while appellate courts expect careful legal analysis, disciplined reasoning, and clear argument about how the law should be applied. Those are the skills that require constant attention of the appellate lawyer to continually perfect. 

A board-certified appellate practitioner places strong emphasis on legal analysis, standards of review, and writing that is clear, concise, and precise. While trial lawyers may review cases to identify helpful precedent, appellate counsel often look more broadly to treatises, scholarly sources, and the structure of the law itself to present the most accurate legal framework to appellate panels.

Appellate counsel also evaluates a case with some distance from the emotional dynamics that can develop during trial. This perspective allows potential legal errors to be examined with fresh eyes. Issues that seemed critical during trial may carry little weight on appeal, while matters that appeared minor may raise significant legal questions under appellate standards. Careful, objective analysis is a central part of the appellate process.

Your browser is not fully compatible with our automatic printer friendly formatting.

Please use the print button to print this profile page.

Spinning circle Big letter B