Insight

If You Can Work Without Accommodation, You Can Still Get ADA Protection: Second Circuit Rejects Defense to ADA Accommodation Claims

Published in The Westchester Litigator

Russell M. Yankwitt

Written by Russell M. Yankwitt

Published: July 23, 2026

The Second Circuit has made it more difficult for employers to defeat Americans with Disabilities Act (“ADA”) failure-to-accommodate claims at the summary judgment stage. In Tudor v. Whitehall Central School District, 132 F.4th 242 (2d Cir. 2025), the Second Circuit became the latest appellate court to hold that an employee’s ability to perform the essential functions of her job without an accommodation does not alone defeat a claim that the employer failed to provide a reasonable accommodation. This recent decision represents a significant clarification of employers’ obligations under the ADA and aligns the Second Circuit with several circuits across the nation.

The Case: Tudor v. Whitehall Central School District, 132 F.4th 242 (2d Cir. 2025)

The plaintiff, a high school teacher suffering from post-traumatic stress disorder (“PTSD”), requested an accommodation permitting her to leave school grounds during scheduled preparation periods to alleviate disability-related symptoms. Although she acknowledged that she could continue performing the essential functions of her position without the requested accommodation, she alleged that doing so caused great duress and harm. The school district denied part of her request, and the plaintiff commenced a suit. Following discovery, the district court granted summary judgment in the district’s favor. The court concluded that because the teacher could perform the essential functions of her job without the accommodation, she could not, as a matter of law, sustain a failure-to-accommodate claim under the ADA.

On appeal, the Second Circuit vacated that decision. Looking to the statutory text, the ADA defines a qualified individual as one who can perform the essential functions of their position “with or without reasonable accommodation.” The court concluded that this language forecloses any categorical rule requiring an employee to prove that an accommodation is indispensable before an employer’s duty to accommodate arises. Congress required employers to provide reasonable accommodations to disabled employees, not merely accommodations to employees who cannot perform the essential functions of the job without them.

In issuing its decision, the court rejected the notion that failure-to-accommodate claims can be resolved through bright-line rules. Whether the requested accommodation is reasonable depends on the facts of the case, and whether an employee’s ability to continue working without an accommodation is only one consideration. Consistent with the ADA’s remedial purpose of eliminating discrimination against those with disabilities, the court held that employers may, in appropriate circumstances, be required to provide accommodations that alleviate disability-related pain or limitations even where the employee remains capable of performing the essential duties of the position. The employer remains free to argue that a requested accommodation is unreasonable or would impose an undue hardship, but it may no longer rely solely on the employee’s ability to continue working as a complete defense.

The Takeaway

Tudor changes the analysis of ADA accommodation requests in the Second Circuit. Employers evaluating accommodation requests should avoid treating an employee’s ability to continue performing the essential functions of the position as the end of the inquiry. After Tudor, the more significant questions are whether the requested accommodation is reasonable under the circumstances and whether providing it would impose an undue hardship.
The decision also serves as a reminder that the ADA is intended to eliminate workplace discrimination, not merely to ensure that employees can perform their jobs. Accommodation requests that were denied because they were viewed as unnecessary now warrant a more individualized assessment. Employers should therefore continue engaging in the interactive, carefully documented process and evaluate accommodation requests on a case-by-case basis rather than relying on categorical rules.

Trending Articles

What AI Visibility Means for Lawyers


by Josh Rupall and Bryan Driscoll

AI tools increasingly interpret lawyers public information. Clear, consistent and credible sources help ensure they describe legal expertise accurately.

AI dashboard visualizing a lawyer's online profile, reputation, and practice information across mult

The Best Lawyers in Canada 2027: Recognizing the Nation's Top Legal Talent


by Jamilla Tabbara

Honoring established leaders and rising practitioners across Canada's legal profession.

3D model of Canada textured with the Canadian flag.

2027 Best Lawyers Awards: Honoring Excellence in the Legal Profession


by Jamilla Tabbara

Recognizing the outstanding attorneys leading top practice areas nationwide.

United States with American flag representing The Best Lawyers in America 2027 awards

2027 Best Lawyers Awards in Brazil, Mexico, Portugal and Spain


by Jamilla Tabbara

Explore key findings from the awards, including recognition figures and emerging legal talent.

3D country maps of Brazil, Mexico, Portugal and Spain with national flags

Announcing the 2027 Best Lawyers Awards: Austria, Germany and Switzerland


by Jamilla Tabbara

Celebrating the legal professionals throughout Central Europe.

Graphic displaying three-dimensional map cutouts of Austria, Germany and Switzerland.

The Best Lawyers in France 2027: Peer-Reviewed Excellence


by Jamilla Tabbara

Seventeen editions of peer trust, a growing profession and a dynamic legal market.

3D Map of France with National Flag Graphic

Who Can Override a Power of Attorney?


by Bryan Driscoll

A power of attorney carries real legal authority, but it isn't absolute. Here's who can step in to revoke, restrict or set it aside.

Close-up of a power of attorney document, symbolizing legal authority, revocation rights, guardiansh

Inside the 2027 Best Lawyers Awards in Chile, Colombia and Puerto Rico


by Jamilla Tabbara

A closer look at the research process, methodology and key statistics behind the 2027 editions.

3D map cutouts of Chile, Colombia, and Puerto Rico

How to Get an Eviction Off Your Record


by Bryan Driscoll

Whether an eviction can be removed, sealed or corrected depends on your state, your case and where the record appears.

A printed eviction notice attached to a decorative metal security gate, representing housing instabi

How Peer Review Works: Best Lawyers Methodology Explained


by Jamilla Tabbara

Understanding the independent, data-driven framework that defines professional legal standing.

A glowing professional icon surrounded by incoming arrows, symbolizing data collection and feedback.

Google Is Losing Major Antitrust Cases. Is This the End of Big Tech’s Winning Streak?


by Justin Smulison

Legal experts say the remedies and appeals, not the liability findings, will determine if Google's losses reshape the tech industry.

Google Antitrust Losses: What They Mean for Big Tech

How to Optimize Your Best Lawyers Profile for AI Search


by Everett Sizemore

Learn how a complete, well-structured Best Lawyers profile can strengthen your visibility and accuracy across AI search platforms.

A laptop screen displaying the Best Lawyers profile dashboard showing customizable sections.

What Is a Hostile Work Environment?


by Bryan Driscoll

Not every difficult job is a hostile work environment in the eyes of the law. Here's how to tell the difference and what to do next.

Blurred image of a distressed employee in an office, surrounded by motion-blurred coworkers, conveyi

Can You Sue Someone for Emotional Distress?


by Bryan Driscoll

Emotional distress can sometimes support a lawsuit, but whether you have a valid claim depends on the facts, the law and your ability to prove real harm.

Abstract black-and-white face with multiple screaming mouths, representing emotional distress, anxie

GEO for Law Firms: What It Is and How to Optimize for AI Search


by Bryan Driscoll and Everett Sizemore

A seven-step audit for law firms that covers the terms, the pages, the outside profiles and what you can actually measure.

Hands typing on a laptop with glowing GEO and AI search graphics

What Is the Downside of Filing for Bankruptcy?


by Bryan Driscoll

A balanced look at the credit, financial and emotional costs of bankruptcy and when filing still makes sense.

A close-up photograph of a weathered, empty red leather wallet lying abandoned.
Tap to expand

Welcome to Smithy AI the Best Lawyers Assistant

I can help you find attorneys, compare firms, explore practice areas, and surface rankings curated from the Best Lawyers methodology.

Not legal advice This assistant provides general information only. For guidance on your specific situation, please consult a licensed attorney.
Learn about Best Lawyers Research Process
Suggested prompts
Chat limit reached
You've reached the message limit for this chat. To keep exploring, browse Best Lawyers directly or come back later to start a fresh conversation.
Browse Best Lawyers