Insight

Government Asks Supreme Court to Weigh in on the Knowledge Element of the False Claims Act: Does Evidence of Subjective Intent Matter in All Cases?

Sherrard Roe Blog

Christopher C. Sabis

Christopher C. Sabis

December 17, 2024 03:46 PM

Government Asks Supreme Court to Weigh in on the Knowledge Element of the False Claims Act: Does Evidence of Subjective Intent Matter in All Cases?

December 8, 2022 | Sherrard Roe Blog | Christopher C. Sabis

The United States has asked the Supreme Court to decide whether the subjective belief of a party accused of submitting a false claim for payment to the Government is sufficient to support a violation when the accused party can articulate a reasonable, if incorrect, interpretation of the governing law. Should the Court accept the Government’s invitation to weigh in, the case could result in the most important False Claims Act (FCA) decision since Universal Health Servs. v. United States ex rel. Escobar.

The request came in a Government amicus brief filed on December 6, 2022, in United States ex rel. Schutte, et al. v. SuperValu Inc., et al. In that case, the relators filed a petition for a writ of certiorari asking the Supreme Court to review the 7th Circuit’s holding that if an FCA defendant can articulate an “objectively reasonable understanding” of the applicable law that is not contradicted by authoritative guidance, then the defendant cannot be held liable for an FCA violation. In SuperValu, the 7th Circuit applied the objective reasonableness test articulated by the Supreme Court in the Fair Credit Reporting Act case Safeco Insurance Company of America v. Burr, to the FCA. It held that a reasonable interpretation of the applicable law was determinative regardless of whether the FCA defendant believed that interpretation at the time of the alleged false claims. The majority reached this conclusion over a vigorous dissent, which argued that an FCA defendant’s “subjective bad faith [was] central to fraudulent scienter.”

Interpreting the knowledge requirement in the FCA is obviously critical to the breadth of activity subject to its provisions. The lack of a divisive circuit split may cause the Court to postpone consideration of this issue, but the United States’ desire to see it addressed makes it likely that the Justices will eventually weigh in. A Supreme Court decision on applying the objective reasonableness standard to the FCA could significantly impact how FCA defense attorneys defend against fraud allegations and how the Department of Justice chooses FCA cases to prosecute in the first place.

Trending Articles

Introducing the 2026 Best Lawyers Awards in Australia, Japan, New Zealand and Singapore


by Jennifer Verta

This year’s awards reflect the strength of the Best Lawyers network and its role in elevating legal talent worldwide.

2026 Best Lawyers Awards in Australia, Japan, New Zealand and Singapore

Revealing the 2026 Best Lawyers Awards in Germany, France, Switzerland and Austria


by Jamilla Tabbara

These honors underscore the reach of the Best Lawyers network and its focus on top legal talent.

map of Germany, France, Switzerland and Austria

Effective Communication: A Conversation with Jefferson Fisher


by Jamilla Tabbara

The power of effective communication beyond the law.

 Image of Jefferson Fisher and Phillip Greer engaged in a conversation about effective communication

The 2025 Legal Outlook Survey Results Are In


by Jennifer Verta

Discover what Best Lawyers honorees see ahead for the legal industry.

Person standing at a crossroads with multiple intersecting paths and a signpost.

The Best Lawyers Network: Global Recognition with Long-term Value


by Jamilla Tabbara

Learn how Best Lawyers' peer-review process helps recognized lawyers attract more clients and referral opportunities.

Lawyers networking

Jefferson Fisher: The Secrets to Influential Legal Marketing


by Jennifer Verta

How lawyers can apply Jefferson Fisher’s communication and marketing strategies to build trust, attract clients and grow their practice.

Portrait of Jefferson Fisher a legal marketing expert

Is Your Law Firm’s Website Driving Clients Away?


by Jamilla Tabbara

Identify key website issues that may be affecting client engagement and retention.

Phone displaying 'This site cannot be reached' message

A Guide to Workers' Compensation Law for 2025 and Beyond


by Bryan Driscoll

A woman with a laptop screen reflected in her glasses

Best Lawyers Launches CMO Advisory Board


by Jamilla Tabbara

Strategic counsel from legal marketing’s most experienced voices.

Group photo of Best Lawyers CMO Advisory Board members

Common Law Firm Landing Page Problems to Address


by Jamilla Tabbara

Identify key issues on law firm landing pages to improve client engagement and conversion.

Laptop showing law firm landing page analytics

Changes in California Employment Law for 2025


by Laurie Villanueva

What employers need to know to ensure compliance in the coming year and beyond

A pair of hands holding a checklist featuring a generic profile picture and the state of California

New Employment Law Recognizes Extraordinary Stress Is Everyday Reality for NY Lawyers


by Bryan Driscoll

A stressed woman has her head resting on her hands above a laptop

Medical Malpractice Reform Trends in Texas, Utah, Georgia and SC


by Bryan Driscoll

A fresh wave of medical malpractice reform is reshaping the law.

Medical Malpractice Reform Trends hed

Why Jack Dorsey and Elon Musk Want to 'Delete All IP Law'


by Bryan Driscoll

This Isn’t Just a Debate Over How to Pay Creators. It’s a Direct Challenge to Legal Infrastructure.

Elon Musk and Jack Dorsey standing together Infront of the X logo

Turn Visitors into Clients with Law Firm Website SEO That Converts


by Jamilla Tabbara

Learn how to create high-converting law firm landing pages that drive client engagement and lead generation.

Laptop screen displaying website tools to improve client conversion rates

Best Lawyers Introduces Smithy AI


by Jamilla Tabbara

Transforming legal content creation for attorneys and firms.

Start using Smithy AI, a content tool by Best Lawyers