Insight

Delaware Supreme Court Affirms Huge Loophole in Collateral Source Rule, Leading to Drastic Reduction in Tort Damages

Delaware Supreme Court Affirms Huge Loophole in Collateral Source Rule, Leading to Drastic Reduction in Tort Damages

John D. Balaguer

John D. Balaguer

May 9, 2019 10:30 AM

By: John D. Balaguer and Christine Kane

The Delaware Supreme Court’s recent opinion in Stayton v. Delaware Health Corporation et al. is good news for tort defendants and liability insurers. The decision mandates significant cuts in medical expenses that tort plaintiffs are permitted to claim in Delaware when Medicare is paying the bills.

In a case of first impression in the State, the High Court held that the collateral source rule, which permits a tort plaintiff to recover medical expenses even when the expenses are paid by a third party, such as private insurance, Medicare or Medicaid, does not apply to Medicare write-offs. The Supreme Court’s decision upheld a trial court ruling from September 2014, "Delaware Court Narrows Collateral Source Rule to End Recovery for Phantom Medical Expenses," and signals a potential shift in Delaware toward more conservative legal rulings on tort issues.

Before Stayton, the collateral source rule permitted plaintiffs in Delaware and in many other states, quite unfairly from a defense perspective, to recover the full amount of medical bills incurred despite the fact that the amount actually paid by Medicare on the bills was a fraction, often a very small fraction, of the original total, with the remaining balance written-off by providers. Therefore, not only were plaintiffs compensated for medical bills they never paid, but also for bills never paid by anyone.

The facts in Stayton underscored the absurdity of this long-standing practice. The plaintiff, a Medicare recipient, suffered severe burns when, left unattended in a nursing home, she set herself ablaze while lighting a cigarette. In her suit against the nursing home, the plaintiff sought compensation for her full $3.6 million hospital bill, although Medicare paid only about $262,000 in full satisfaction of the bill. Under its contract with Medicare, the hospital was required to accept the much lower amount and write off the balance.

The Court reasoned that these reductions and resulting write-offs are not payments made to the injured party and do not benefit the injured party, so the collateral source rule should not apply to them. The Court distinguished bill reductions made by private insurance, which are negotiated for the plaintiff who paid the insurance premium, from cuts made by the government for the benefit of all taxpayers. In coming to this decision, the Court also focused on the underlying purpose of compensatory damages - to put a plaintiff in as close to the same position as he/she was in before the injury. In other words, compensatory damages should make a plaintiff “whole," but no more.

The Court acknowledged that the collateral source rule is intended to strike a balance between making a plaintiff whole on one hand and the competing imperative to make a defendant liable for all damages proximately resulting from his wrong. Granted, in attempting to strike this balance, the rule errs on the side of giving the plaintiff – rather than the defendant – a windfall, in the form of a double recovery, when medical expenses or other damages are paid by a third party source unconnected to the defendant. But at the same time, the Court decided that it simply took the principle too far, and indeed defied logic, to allow a plaintiff to be compensated at more than 13 times the medical expenses paid out, particularly when the difference was not paid by anyone.

The ruling in Stayton limits tort plaintiffs in Delaware to compensation for the actual amount paid by Medicare to satisfy their bills, and no more. While the Stayton case specifically addresses only payments made by Medicare, the Court’s reasoning would seem to apply with equal force to any government benefit or public collateral source that covers medical expenses, such as Medicaid.

In catastrophic injury cases enormous medical expenses and the collateral source rule often work together to unfairly drive up settlements and verdicts. However, the Stayton decision means there will be fewer such windfalls for plaintiffs in Delaware tort litigation. This case should be cited to significantly reduce “boardable” damages whenever an injured plaintiff whose medical bills were paid by a public collateral source seeks to recover more than what the government actually paid to satisfy the bills.

John Balaguer and Christine Kane represent individual healthcare providers and institutions in civil lawsuits and administrative proceedings throughout Delaware and are part of the Healthcare Practice Group. Please do not hesitate to contact John (302.467.4501; balaguerj@whiteandwilliams.com) or Christine (302-467-4504; kanec@whiteandwilliams.com) with any questions about this topic or related healthcare and other tort law matters.

Related Articles

Adoption of “Emergency Bylaws” Continues


by Benjamin R. Foster, David Clark and Shenna N. Johnson

The disruption to businesses stemming from the COVID-19 pandemic that took hold in 2020 prompted renewed focus on corporate governance under emergency conditions.

Emergency Bylaws in Delaware

In the News: Texas 2019


by Best Lawyers

A roundup of relevant news from lawyers listed in Texas.

Legal News Roundup Texas

Health Care Prime


by Andrew Kinworthy, Jonathan K. Henderson, Kevin McDonell and Robert A. Guy, Jr.

How will M&A shape the American health industry going forward? By adhering to the Amazon model.

Health Care on Demand

The Power of Two


by Dale Van Demark and Kerrin B. Slattery

More health care companies than ever see the value of robust partnerships in a constantly changing industry.

Health Care and the Private Sector

Insurance Coverage to Protect the Health Care Industry from the Increasing Risks Associated with the Internet of Things


by Meghan Magruder and Amy Dehnel

While this connectivity can provide great benefits to patients and physicians, the security issues inherent in these devices are critical.

Insurance for Health Care Industry

The New Era for Health Care Services in the United States


by Bobby Guy & Brook Bailey

The future of Obamacare is unclear, and what U.S. health care will look like when the political fuss is over is an inquiry punctuated by a very large question mark.

Health Care Services

Public Health Reform: What does the future look like for patients?


by Vanessa Mellis

Increased government stewardship and a stronger user orientation are two of the key elements shaping this process.

Public Health Reform

Trending Articles

Announcing the 2023 The Best Lawyers in America Honorees


by Best Lawyers

Only the top 5.3% of all practicing lawyers in the U.S. were selected by their peers for inclusion in the 29th edition of The Best Lawyers in America®.

Gold strings and dots connecting to form US map

Announcing the 2022 Best Lawyers® in the United States


by Best Lawyers

The results include an elite field of top lawyers listed in the 28th Edition of The Best Lawyers in America® and in the 2nd Edition of Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch in America for 2022.

2022 Best Lawyers Listings for United States

2021 Best Lawyers: The Global Issue


by Best Lawyers

The 2021 Global Issue features top legal talent from the most recent editions of Best Lawyers and Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch worldwide.

2021 Best Lawyers: The Global Issue

The U.S. Best Lawyers Voting Season Is Open


by Best Lawyers

The voting season for the 31st edition of The Best Lawyers in America® and the 5th edition of Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch® in America is officially underway, and we are offering some helpful advice to this year’s voters.

Golden figures of people standing on blue surface connected by white lines

How To Find A Pro Bono Lawyer


by Best Lawyers

Best Lawyers dives into the vital role pro bono lawyers play in ensuring access to justice for all and the transformative impact they have on communities.

Hands joined around a table with phone, paper, pen and glasses

What the Courts Say About Recording in the Classroom


by Christina Henagen Peer and Peter Zawadski

Students and parents are increasingly asking to use audio devices to record what's being said in the classroom. But is it legal? A recent ruling offer gives the answer to a question confusing parents and administrators alike.

Is It Legal for Students to Record Teachers?

How Palworld Is Testing the Limits of Nintendo’s Legal Power


by Gregory Sirico

Many are calling the new game Palworld “Pokémon GO with guns,” noting the games striking similarities. Experts speculate how Nintendo could take legal action.

Animated figures with guns stand on top of creatures

The Best Lawyers in Australia™ 2024 Launch


by Best Lawyers

Best Lawyers is excited to announce The Best Lawyers in Australia™ for 2023, including the top lawyers and law firms from Australia.

Australian Parliament beside water at sunset

Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch in America for 2023


by Best Lawyers

The third edition of Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch in America™ highlights the legal talent of lawyers who have been in practice less than 10 years.

Three arrows made of lines and dots on blue background

Inflation Escalation


by Ashley S. Wagner

Inflation and rising costs are at the forefront of everyone’s mind as we enter 2023. The current volatile market makes it more important than ever to understand the rent escalation clauses in current and future commercial lease agreements.

Suited figure in front of rising market and inflated balloon

A Celebration of Excellence: The Best Lawyers in Canada 2024 Awards


by Best Lawyers

As we embark on the 18th edition of The Best Lawyers in Canada™, we are excited to highlight excellence and top legal talent across the country.

Abstract image of red and white Canada flag in triangles

8 Different Types of Criminal Defenses in Law


by Best Lawyers

Learn about the different types of criminal defenses available in law, including innocence, self-defense, insanity and more. Protect your rights today.

Silver handcuffs laying on finger printed papers

Wage and Overtime Laws for Truck Drivers


by Greg Mansell

For truck drivers nationwide, underpayment and overtime violations are just the beginning of a long list of problems. Below we explore the wages you are entitled to but may not be receiving.

Truck Driver Wage and Overtime Laws in the US

The Upcycle Conundrum


by Karen Kreider Gaunt

Laudable or litigious? What you need to know about potential copyright and trademark infringement when repurposing products.

Repurposed Products and Copyright Infringemen

Choosing a Title Company: What a Seller Should Expect


by Roy D. Oppenheim

When it comes to choosing a title company, how much power exactly does a seller have?

Choosing the Title Company As Seller

Unwrapping Shrinkflation


by Justin Smulison

Through the lens of the United States, we take a closer look at the global implication of companies downsizing products while maintaining and often raising prices.

Chocolate bar being unwrapped from foil