Insight

Average Settlement for a Shoulder Injury From a Car Accident in NJ

This guide will walk through what you need to know about car accident shoulder injuries, average settlement ranges, and the key factors that impact your case.

Jared C. Glugeth

Jared C. Glugeth

October 29, 2025 11:30 AM

Dealing with shoulder pain following a car accident can be overwhelming, and seeking compensation might be the farthest thing from your mind. Your primary concerns are likely focused on medical treatments, time off work, and the extended recovery period. However, once financial obligations begin to accumulate, addressing the question of compensation becomes essential: What is a typical settlement for shoulder injury cases in a car accident?

At Glugeth & Pierguidi, P.C., we recognize the challenges you face during this difficult time. Our dedicated attorneys, Jared Glugeth and David Pierguidi, have worked with numerous clients to navigate injury claims and strive for fair settlements. We provide comprehensive explanations of the process, respond to your inquiries, and offer support throughout your recovery journey.

Let’s explore critical information about shoulder injuries from car accidents, potential settlement ranges, and factors influencing your case.

Understanding Car Accident Shoulder Injuries

The shoulder, as one of the body’s complex joints, is susceptible to injuries during a car crash. These injuries can range from mild sprains to severe cases requiring surgery. Common injuries include:

  • Rotator cuff tears
  • Dislocations
  • Impingement syndromes
  • Bursitis
  • Fractures

Given the shoulder's pivotal role in daily activities, even minor injuries can result in substantial difficulties. Persistent pain, reduced mobility, and challenges in fulfilling work or familial duties are common outcomes. Additionally, the recovery process can be prolonged, often involving physical therapy or repeated interventions to restore function.

Average Settlement Amounts for Shoulder Injuries

Determining the worth of a shoulder injury case is not straightforward, as settlements vary based on individual circumstances such as injury severity, necessary treatments, and long-term impacts.

More serious injuries, particularly those necessitating surgery, often result in higher compensation amounts. Although an “average” figure is challenging to establish, insurance providers often refer to past verdicts and settlements in similar cases when formulating offers. Therefore, having proficient legal representation is crucial in advocating for compensation that covers medical needs, lost earnings, and enduring pain.

In New Jersey, the modified comparative negligence rule applies. If you hold partial responsibility for the incident, your compensation might be adjusted. Nevertheless, as long as your fault is below 50%, you may still receive damages.

Factors Affecting Shoulder Injury Compensation

Several factors are considered by insurers and courts when evaluating shoulder injury compensation, including:

  1. Medical costs—hospital visits, physical therapy, medications, and surgeries;
  2. Lost wages—loss of past and future income due to the inability to work;
  3. Pain and suffering—both physical pain and emotional distress caused by the injury;
  4. Permanent disability—any long-term movement restriction or chronic discomfort; and
  5. Fault and liability—establishing the other driver’s negligence.

Each case is distinct. For example, an individual with a physically strenuous job might incur higher damages if the injury affects career prospects permanently. Additionally, restrictions on engaging in hobbies, sports, or even routine household chores are factored into the compensation amount.

Settlements for Different Types of Shoulder Injuries

One of the primary factors affecting settlement value is the necessity for surgery. A settlement involving surgical intervention typically involves higher compensation due to increased medical expenses, extended recovery durations, and a greater degree of life disruption.

For instance, rotator cuff surgery can range from $15,000 to $50,000, with recovery spanning several months involving extensive physical therapy, necessitating careful consideration of long-term expenses during settlement discussions.

Torn Rotator Cuff Car Accident Settlement

A torn rotator cuff is both common and debilitating. Settlements for this injury might be above average given the severe pain and potential need for surgery. Many rotator cuff tears do not self-heal, leading to sustained medical requirements.

Shoulder Impingement Car Accident Settlement

In cases where rotator cuff tendons are compressed during movement, it can result in persistent pain and weakness. Settlements for shoulder impingement usually include costs for ongoing treatment such as injections, physical therapy, or in some instances, surgery to alleviate tendon pressure.

Shoulder Bursitis Car Accident Settlement

Shoulder bursitis occurs when shoulder joint cushioning sacs become inflamed, potentially resulting in severe pain and restricted mobility. Compensation for such injuries considers medical costs and lost earnings but may not match settlements for surgical injuries.

Why Legal Representation Matters

Insurance providers might underappreciate the value of shoulder injury claims by suggesting pre-existing conditions or exaggeration of symptoms. Securing robust legal representation ensures you’re equipped to counter such minimizations and pursue adequate compensation.

At Glugeth & Pierguidi, P.C., we diligently compile medical evidence, consult specialists, and consider the injury's full impact on your life. Our aim extends beyond achieving a settlement to accessing the maximum compensation permissible under New Jersey law.

Taking the Next Step Toward Recovery

If you are experiencing shoulder pain after a car accident, navigating the compensation process can be daunting. You don’t have to face this challenge on your own. At Glugeth & Pierguidi, P.C., we provide responsive service and committed representation. We thoroughly evaluate your case, resist insurance company strategies, and strive for the compensation necessary to move forward with your life.

Contact Glugeth & Pierguidi, P.C. today for a consultation. Supported by extensive experience and a history of results, we are here to assist you in pursuing the settlement you require to regain your life’s trajectory.

Trending Articles

2026 Best Lawyers Awards: Recognizing Legal Talent Across the United States


by Jamilla Tabbara

The 2026 editions highlight the top 5% of U.S. attorneys, showcase emerging practice areas and reveal trends shaping the nation’s legal profession.

Map of the United States represented in The Best Lawyers in America 2026 awards

Gun Rights for Convicted Felons? The DOJ Says It's Time.


by Bryan Driscoll

It's more than an administrative reopening of a long-dormant issue; it's a test of how the law reconciles the right to bear arms with protecting the public.

Firearms application behind jail bars

2026 Best Lawyers Awards in Canada: Marking 20 Years of Excellence


by Jamilla Tabbara

Honoring Canada’s most respected lawyers and spotlighting the next generation shaping the future of law.

Shining Canadian map marking the 2026 Best Lawyers awards coverage

Revealing the 2026 Best Lawyers Awards in Germany, France, Switzerland and Austria


by Jamilla Tabbara

These honors underscore the reach of the Best Lawyers network and its focus on top legal talent.

map of Germany, France, Switzerland and Austria

Best Lawyers 2026: Discover the Honorees in Brazil, Mexico, Portugal, South Africa and Spain


by Jamilla Tabbara

A growing international network of recognized legal professionals.

Map highlighting the 2026 Best Lawyers honorees across Brazil, Mexico, Portugal, South Africa and Sp

How to Sue for Defamation: Costs, Process and What to Expect


by Bryan Driscoll

Learn the legal standards, costs and steps involved when you sue for defamation, including the difference between libel and slander.

Group of people holding papers with speech bubbles above them

Build Your Legal Practice with Effective Online Networking


by Jamilla Tabbara

How thoughtful online networking supports sustained legal practice growth.

Abstract web of connected figures symbolizing online networking among legal professionals

Algorithmic Exclusion


by Bryan Driscoll

The Workday lawsuit and the future of AI in hiring.

Workday Lawsuit and the Future of AI in Hiring headline

Blogging for Law Firms: Turning Content into Client Connections


by Jamilla Tabbara

How law firms use blogs to earn trust and win clients.

Lawyer typing blog content on laptop in office

Reddit’s Lawsuit Could Change How Much AI Knows About You


by Justin Smulison

Big AI is battling for its future—your data’s at stake.

Reddit Anthropic Lawsuit headline

How to Choose a Good Lawyer: Tips, Traits and Questions to Ask


by Laurie Villanueva

A Practical Guide for Your First-Time Hiring a Lawyer

Three professional lawyers walking together and discussing work

The 2026 Best Lawyers Awards in Chile, Colombia and Puerto Rico


by Jamilla Tabbara

The region’s most highly regarded lawyers.

Map highlighting Chile, Colombia and Puerto Rico for the 2026 Best Lawyers Awards

Common-Law Marriage in Indiana: Are You Legally Protected?


by Laurie Villanueva

Understanding cohabitation rights and common-law marriage recognition in Indiana.

Married Indiana couple in their home

Why Jack Dorsey and Elon Musk Want to 'Delete All IP Law'


by Bryan Driscoll

This Isn’t Just a Debate Over How to Pay Creators. It’s a Direct Challenge to Legal Infrastructure.

Elon Musk and Jack Dorsey standing together Infront of the X logo

AI Tools for Lawyers: How Smithy AI Solves Key Challenges


by Jamilla Tabbara

Understand the features and benefits within the Best Lawyers Digital Marketing Platform.

Legal professional editing profile content with Smithy AI

Alimony Explained: Who Qualifies, How It Works and What to Expect


by Bryan Driscoll

A practical guide to understanding alimony, from eligibility to enforcement, for anyone navigating divorce

two figures standing on stacks of coins